Nicalis Removes AI Music from Binding of Isaac After Players Expose Suno Metadata

Nicalis removed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players identified Suno metadata in a new Grand Theft Auto 6-themed mode. Creator Edmund McMillen stated he was unaware of the inclusion, and the controversy triggered a severe review bomb on Steam.
Key points
- Players discovered AI-generated tracks in a special 'Vice City' daily run mode added to Repentance+ on November 19, 2026.
- Reddit user ShweetsStuff identified Suno metadata in the audio files, prompting immediate backlash and negative Steam reviews.
- Edmund McMillen admitted he was unaware of the AI usage and confirmed Nicalis was working to remove the files.
- Nicalis pushed a patch to remove the music and fix bugs, submitting updates to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony.
- The game's Steam rating plummeted to 9% positive due to the AI controversy and pre-existing quality issues.
Background
The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ is a free update to the long-running roguelike, adding online co-op and quality-of-life improvements. It launched on console in November 2026, coinciding with the release of Grand Theft Auto 6. Previous expansions, including Repentance in 2021, have significantly expanded the game's content and player base.
How outlets are covering it
Eurogamer and Kotaku emphasize the severity of the backlash, noting the Steam rating dropped to 9% positive and highlighting player anger over undisclosed AI content. GoNintendo focuses on the technical discovery of Suno metadata and the subsequent removal. Kotaku notes that Nicalis has not explained how the AI music was included, while Eurogamer highlights McMillen's admission of ignorance regarding the tracks. All sources agree on the removal of the music and the creator's public response.
Why it matters
This incident highlights growing player resistance to undisclosed AI-generated content in games, particularly when it coincides with major industry releases. It underscores the importance of transparency in game development and the potential for rapid community backlash to impact a game's reputation and sales.
What to watch
Nicalis is expected to provide further explanation on how the AI music was included. The game may receive additional patches to address ongoing bugs and quality issues. Players may continue to monitor the game's Steam rating and community sentiment in the coming weeks.
- The Binding of Isaac's new update was review-bombed over AI-generated music, and now it's been removed Eurogamer.net
- The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Online mode appears to contain AI generated music, creator working on getting it removed GoNintendo
- 'Woke Up to a S**t Show' — The Binding of Isaac Creator Says He Was Unaware of Now-Removed AI-Generated Music in Repentance+ Following Backlash IGN
- Edmund McMillen Discusses The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Cubed3
- Binding Of Isaac Update Review-Bombed Over AI-Generated Music In GTA 6 Mode: 'Woke Up To A Sh*t Show, Obviously I Had No Idea' Kotaku
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Eurogamer.net