7,000-step walk test: Fitbit Air narrowly edges Garmin Cirqa in accuracy

In a hands-on 7,000-step walk test, the Fitbit Air narrowly outperformed the Garmin Cirqa. The Air undercounted by about 10 steps while the Cirqa overcounted by roughly 70; Strava data aligned with Air for distance, but Cirqa logged the workout as a generic outdoor workout and didn’t record distance or climb. Heart-rate data were inconsistent between devices, making a definitive accuracy call difficult. Overall, the Air wins by a small margin, though Cirqa showed potential but less reliable outdoor metrics.