Barnham Votes 257-16 to Symbolically Secede Over Asylum Base Plans

3 min read
Source: The Independent
Barnham Votes 257-16 to Symbolically Secede Over Asylum Base Plans
Photo: The Independent
TL;DR

Residents of Barnham, Suffolk, voted 257 to 16 in a symbolic referendum to leave the UK, protesting government plans to house 931 asylum seekers at the nearby RAF Barnham base. The vote, which carries no legal weight, follows a similar secession vote in Piddington, Oxfordshire. While the Home Office maintains that final decisions are pending and emphasizes security measures, critics argue the plan ignores environmental concerns and community safety. Local leaders propose 'crown dependency' status to bypass Home Office jurisdiction, while opposition leaders express mixed views on the accommodation strategy.

Key points

  • Barnham residents voted 257 to 16 in a symbolic referendum to leave the UK, protesting plans to house 931 asylum seekers at RAF Barnham.
  • The vote carries no legal weight but aims to pressure the Home Office to reconsider its accommodation strategy.
  • Local leaders propose 'crown dependency' status to bypass Home Office jurisdiction, similar to Jersey and Guernsey.
  • The Home Office maintains that final decisions are pending and emphasizes security measures, including 24/7 security and CCTV.
  • Critics argue the plan ignores environmental concerns, particularly the presence of stone-curlews, and community safety.

Background

This follows a similar symbolic referendum in Piddington, Oxfordshire, in September, where residents voted to secede from the UK after the government announced plans to house 1,256 male asylum seekers at a nearby former military base. The Barnham vote is part of a broader debate over the government's strategy for housing asylum seekers, which has faced criticism from both local communities and opposition parties.

How outlets are covering it

The Independent and The Guardian report on the symbolic nature of the vote and the lack of legal weight, while The Telegraph emphasizes the environmental concerns and the potential impact on the stone-curlew population. The ITVX report highlights the government's response, emphasizing security measures and the closure of asylum hotels. The local MP, Dr Peter Prinsley, criticizes the plan as resembling a 'concentration camp' and suggests that disused office blocks in larger cities may be more appropriate. The Home Office maintains that the plans are part of a fairer distribution of asylum accommodation and that the sites are designed to be self-contained with security measures. Opposition leaders, including Kemi Badenoch, support the villagers' concerns but argue that the government needs to stop the boats rather than spreading the problem around.

Why it matters

The Barnham referendum highlights the growing tension between local communities and the government over asylum accommodation plans. The symbolic vote, while having no legal weight, serves as a powerful expression of community dissent and may influence future policy decisions. The environmental concerns, particularly the presence of stone-curlews, could potentially scupper the plans, as the site lies within a special protection area. The debate over the appropriate location for asylum accommodation is likely to continue, with both local communities and opposition parties pushing for a more compassionate and practical approach.

What to watch

The Home Office has not made a final decision on the RAF Barnham proposal, but the construction firm Kier has been awarded a £3.4m contract to draw up detailed designs. The Home Office intends to use a fast-track planning route that bypasses the local planning authority. If approved, the site would operate for at least a decade. The environmental concerns, particularly the presence of stone-curlews, could potentially scupper the plans, as the site lies within a special protection area. The debate over the appropriate location for asylum accommodation is likely to continue, with both local communities and opposition parties pushing for a more compassionate and practical approach.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Independent