True Crime News

The latest true crime stories, summarized by AI

More True Crime Stories

Oklahoma teen avoids prison after completing youthful-offender probation in brutal rape case
true-crime19 days ago

Oklahoma teen avoids prison after completing youthful-offender probation in brutal rape case

In Stillwater, Oklahoma, Jesse Butler, who was 17 when charged with 11 counts including first-degree rape and strangulation of two teen girls, had his case dismissed after completing youthful offender probation, avoiding any prison time; the district attorney plans to pursue federal review and a civil action may follow, while Butler’s record may be expunged.

Monsoon rains may reshape clues in Nancy Guthrie disappearance
true-crime20 days ago

Monsoon rains may reshape clues in Nancy Guthrie disappearance

In Tucson, neighbors say FBI investigators returned to search the brush behind Nancy Guthrie’s home as her six-month disappearance nears, while officials say no task force has recently returned. A retired sheriff’s lieutenant suggests heavy monsoon rains could have exposed or moved evidence and altered the landscape, potentially prompting renewed scrutiny. Authorities continue pursuing leads, reviewing thousands of videos, and offering a reward pool exceeding $1.2 million for information about Guthrie, the mother of NBC’s Savannah Guthrie, who vanished on Feb. 1.

Third Suspect Arrested in Nolan Wells Case Over Threats to Witnesses
true-crime21 days ago

Third Suspect Arrested in Nolan Wells Case Over Threats to Witnesses

Edward James Porter, 40, has become the third person arrested in the Nolan Wells case after authorities say he transmitted threats in interstate commerce, telling a witness he would “come kill” them and sharing the witness’s home address. Wells disappeared July 4 on Horn Island, Mississippi and was found dead July 6; two earlier arrests—Joseph Alfredo Vasquez Dumarce and Michelle Francine Edwards—were for related threats. Wells’ family, represented by Ben Crump, has faced online abuse as the investigation continues, with no charges yet tied to Wells’ death.

Guthrie Abduction Notes Echo Unabomber Playbook to Spur Tips
true-crime23 days ago

Guthrie Abduction Notes Echo Unabomber Playbook to Spur Tips

The Pima County Sheriff's Department released two ransom notes in Nancy Guthrie's Tucson disappearance, with a retired investigator saying the release mirrors the Unabomber case’s tactic of publishing the writer’s words to elicit tips. Experts note the notes’ distinctive linguistic style could help identify the sender, though the notes are just one piece of the investigation as authorities seek leads ahead of the six‑month mark; the case carries a $1.2 million reward and remains active.

UK woman lured to Florida allegedly murdered by online acquaintance
true-crime24 days ago

UK woman lured to Florida allegedly murdered by online acquaintance

A Florida man, Dwain Hall, is charged with premeditated first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, a Portsmouth, England woman who flew to rural North Florida after meeting him online and reportedly agreed to be killed for cash. Exelby’s body was found in a Marion County shallow grave in October 2025; investigators say the pair plotted the killing, devised a cover story, and Hall purchased items (including a shovel) and charged expenses to Exelby’s debit card. Exelby had sent messages expressing fear and regret, and a video recovered from Hall shows her distressed during questioning. Hall faces potential the death penalty, with a trial set for November 5 in Marion County.

Postal Worker Arrested in Florida for Stealing Winning Lottery Ticket
true-crime24 days ago

Postal Worker Arrested in Florida for Stealing Winning Lottery Ticket

A Broward County USPS letter carrier, Lakaysha Lockhart, was arrested on July 23 after allegedly stealing a Florida Lottery winning ticket from the mail and redeeming a $2,600 prize at the Florida Lottery Miami District Office. The joint Florida Lottery Security and USPS OIG investigation said Lockhart admitted taking the ticket and cashing it. She faces multiple charges, including grand theft, mail theft, dealing in stolen property, filing a false claim for payment, and two counts of unlawful use of a two-way communications device; cases will be prosecuted separately due to multi-circuit jurisdiction.

DNA Hair Test Hits a Dead End in Guthrie Disappearance
true-crime26 days ago

DNA Hair Test Hits a Dead End in Guthrie Disappearance

A hair found at Nancy Guthrie's Tucson home yielded no DNA profile, but investigators say the sample remains preserved and could still help; with the FBI, authorities sent it to a California lab as part of ongoing DNA analysis across multiple labs, including investigative genetic genealogy, as Guthrie's disappearance nears the six-month mark; a reward over $1.2 million remains, and tips are urged.