NC Judge Orders Raleigh Wedding Photographer to Pay $1.7M After Failing to Deliver Services
A North Carolina judge has ordered Holly Christina Photography to pay nearly $1.7 million in refunds and civil penalties after the company failed to deliver paid-for wedding photos and videos to hundreds of clients. The ruling follows a default judgment motion by the state Attorney General, who cited over 220 consumer complaints and the owners' failure to comply with previous court orders to return footage or issue refunds. The owners, Holly and Christopher Ayscue, were barred from accepting future advance payments and must deliver all remaining assets to clients.
Key points
- A judge granted a default judgment in favor of the North Carolina Attorney General's Office against Holly Christina Photography.
- The court ordered the company to pay approximately $1.7 million, comprising $600,000 in customer refunds and over $1 million in civil penalties.
- The state filed the lawsuit in February after receiving more than 220 complaints from consumers who paid for services but never received them.
- The company failed to comply with a May court order requiring it to turn over all undelivered photos and videos within 30 days.
- The owners are prohibited from offering photography services or accepting advance payments in the future.
Background
This case emerged after WRAL’s 5 On Your Side first reported on the issue in January, leading to the company’s announced closure in February. The dispute centers on a Raleigh-area business that collected payments for wedding photography but failed to deliver the final products to clients. The legal battle intensified when a judge issued a preliminary injunction in May, ordering the company to stop doing business and return all assets to paying customers. The owners previously cited illness as a contributing factor to the business's failure, but the court found they did not meet the requirements of the injunction.
Why it matters
The ruling highlights the strict enforcement of consumer protection laws in North Carolina and serves as a warning to service providers regarding the legal consequences of failing to deliver paid-for services. It also demonstrates the state Attorney General's active role in protecting consumers from fraudulent business practices, particularly in the wedding industry where large advance payments are common. The significant financial penalty underscores the severity of the harm caused to the 220+ affected couples.
What to watch
The Ayscues must now comply with the court order to deliver all remaining photo and video footage to the affected consumers. They are also barred from accepting any future advance payments for photography services. The state will likely monitor the distribution of the $600,000 in refunds to ensure all 142 consumers who did not receive refunds through their financial institutions are compensated.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on WRAL