Federal judge upholds Oregon's producer-funded recycling law against constitutional challenge

U.S. District Judge Michael Simon ruled that Oregon's Plastic Pollution and Recycling Modernization Act does not violate the U.S. Constitution, rejecting claims by the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors that the law unfairly burdens out-of-state businesses. The decision lifts a preliminary injunction, allowing the state to continue charging producers fees to fund recycling infrastructure. While the judge praised Oregon's 'innovative leadership' in shifting waste costs away from taxpayers, the plaintiff association stated it is considering an appeal to the Ninth Circuit. This ruling is significant as Oregon was the first state to implement such a system, and similar laws face legal challenges in California and Colorado.
Key points
- Judge Michael Simon ruled that Oregon's recycling law does not violate the dormant Commerce Clause or the Due Process Clause.
- The National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors (NAW) sued in 2025, arguing the law discriminates against out-of-state businesses and imposes unreviewable fees.
- The ruling lifts a preliminary injunction that had temporarily halted packaging payment requirements for NAW members.
- Oregon was the first state to launch an Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) system in July 2025, shifting recycling costs from governments to corporations.
- NAW represents 30,000 businesses in the $8.6 trillion wholesale distribution industry and is challenging similar laws in California and Colorado.
Background
Oregon enacted its Plastic Pollution and Recycling Modernization Act in 2021, becoming the first state to officially launch its recycling system and begin charging producers fees in July 2025. The system requires producers to pay fees based on the packaging they introduce to the state, funding standardized recycling services and infrastructure. Prior to this ruling, a federal judge had granted NAW a preliminary injunction in February 2026, temporarily blocking enforcement while the case proceeded. The current decision follows a five-day bench trial that concluded in July 2026.
How outlets are covering it
OPB highlights the state's victory as a recognition of Oregon's authority to modernize its recycling system, quoting DEQ officials who expressed satisfaction with the court's validation of the state's 'police powers' to mitigate waste. Packaging Dive emphasizes the legal significance of the ruling for other states, noting that the judge rejected NAW's claims that fees were 'clearly excessive' and that the program favored in-state producers. While OPB focuses on the immediate lifting of the injunction and the potential for non-compliance penalties, Packaging Dive details the judge's reasoning that EPR laws correct market externalities and that NAW failed to provide sufficient evidence for strict scrutiny. Both sources note NAW's disappointment and its intention to review next steps, including a potential appeal, but Packaging Dive provides more detail on the judge's dismissal of due process claims regarding the private organization managing the program.
Why it matters
This ruling sets a precedent for Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) laws across the United States. By upholding Oregon's law, the court provides a legal framework that may influence ongoing litigation in California and Colorado, where similar laws face challenges from industry groups and state attorneys general. The decision validates the model of shifting end-of-life product costs from taxpayers to producers, potentially encouraging other states to adopt similar measures to fund recycling infrastructure and waste prevention.
What to watch
The National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors has indicated it is considering an appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. If appealed, the case will test the constitutionality of EPR laws at a higher federal level. Meanwhile, Oregon's Department of Environmental Quality will continue implementing the law, and producers will resume paying fees. The outcome of this case may also impact parallel lawsuits in California and Colorado, where NAW is leading challenges against similar packaging EPR laws.
- Federal judge sides with Oregon’s recycling law Oregon Public Broadcasting - OPB
- Oregon EPR law doesn’t violate Constitution, judge rules Packaging Dive
- Federal court rules Oregon’s ‘landmark’ recycling law is constitutional KOIN.com
- Federal court upholds Oregon plastics EPR law Plastics News
- District Court Upholds Oregon’s Packaging EPR Law JD Supra
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Oregon Public Broadcasting - OPB