Federal Court Rejects CFTC Bid to Block New York Kalshi Hearing

A federal judge denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s request to block New York from pursuing a temporary restraining order against prediction market Kalshi. This decision clears the path for a state court hearing on Monday, where judges will decide if Kalshi must halt operations. Kalshi argues that a state ban would force a nationwide shutdown due to its New York headquarters, while New York alleges the platform runs illegal gambling operations.
Key points
- U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield rejected the CFTC’s emergency bid to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from seeking a restraining order against Kalshi.
- New York Judge Melissa Crane is scheduled to hear James’s request for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET on Monday.
- Kalshi argues that an order barring operations 'within or from New York' would effectively shut down its exchange nationwide and force the liquidation of open positions.
- New York alleges Kalshi operates an unlicensed gambling business, allowing users under 21 to trade and advertising on college campuses, in violation of state laws.
- The CFTC previously issued an emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating, creating a potential conflict with any state court injunction.
Background
The dispute stems from a lawsuit filed by New York Attorney General Letitia James in July 2026, alleging Kalshi runs an illegal gambling operation. The CFTC and the Department of Justice sued New York in April, arguing that federal law preempts state gambling regulations for federally registered exchanges. Federal appeals courts have split on this issue, with the Fourth, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits siding with states, while the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi. Utah has also brought criminal charges against Kalshi co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara.
How outlets are covering it
The CFTC and Kalshi argue that federal law preempts state gambling laws, and that a state ban would cause an 'existential threat' to the business by forcing a nationwide shutdown. New York counters that the CFTC’s emergency order is a 'collusive effort' and that Kalshi’s contracts constitute sports betting, not federally regulated swaps. Robinhood, which offers event contracts through Kalshi, is shifting its flow to other platforms by year-end, potentially mitigating the impact of a state ban. The Trump administration has actively defended Kalshi, with Donald Trump Jr. serving as an advisor to both Kalshi and Polymarket.
Why it matters
The outcome of the Monday hearing could set a precedent for whether states can regulate prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. A nationwide shutdown would disrupt markets for sports, culture, and elections, affecting millions of users. The case also highlights the tension between federal and state regulatory authority in the digital gambling space, with potential implications for the U.S. Supreme Court.
What to watch
New York Judge Melissa Crane will hear the request for a temporary restraining order on Monday. If granted, it could force Kalshi to halt operations in New York, potentially triggering a nationwide shutdown. The CFTC’s preliminary injunction request in its separate federal case remains pending. Kalshi plans to offer stock and ETF trading within two months through FB Securities, a New York broker it acquired in July.
- Kalshi faces Monday hearing on New York order it says would shut down its exchange nationwide The Block
- Kalshi Claims New York’s Lawsuit Could Shut It Down Everywhere Gizmodo
- US judge rejects CFTC emergency bid to block New York from policing Kalshi Reuters
- Kalshi Says New York Could Shut It Down Nationwide Yahoo Finance
- Administration tries to intervene after Kalshi is threatened with restraining order ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Block