NC Utilities Commissioner Van der Vaart Resigns After Duke Energy Rate Dissent

Donald van der Vaart will resign from the North Carolina Utilities Commission effective January 1, 2027, following his dissent on a recent Duke Energy rate decision. The departure leaves a vacancy just weeks before Democrats take control of the state House.
Key points
- Van der Vaart, appointed by Treasurer Brad Briner in April 2025, is stepping down four and a half years early.
- He dissented from a ruling approving roughly 9% residential rate increases for Duke Energy over two years.
- The dissent argued that current data center rules could leave everyday customers paying for infrastructure if large tech firms break contracts early.
- Briner stated he would announce a replacement in the coming days or weeks.
- The resignation coincides with the effective date of Duke’s new rate increases and utility merger.
Background
The NC Utilities Commission recently approved rate hikes and new data center tariffs after months of public hearings. This follows earlier regulatory shifts that reduced the commission’s size and altered appointment structures, a change currently being challenged in the NC Supreme Court.
How outlets are covering it
WRAL.com and The News & Observer confirm the resignation and note that van der Vaart missed key hearings, including the carbon plan vote. Carolina Journal highlights his detailed dissent, where he argued for a lower 9.25% return on equity and warned that 6.7 gigawatts of new data center load could cost $18 to $19 billion to serve. Axios focuses on the approved rate increases, noting that typical residential bills will rise by $6.53 to $9.62 monthly depending on the region, while environmental groups criticized the approved carbon plan for delaying coal retirements.
Why it matters
The resignation creates a political opening on the commission just before a change in state House leadership. It also highlights ongoing tensions over how the costs of massive data center infrastructure are allocated between utilities, large corporate customers, and residential ratepayers in North Carolina.
What to watch
Treasurer Brad Briner is expected to name a new commissioner soon. The new appointee will join a commission that is currently split between three Republicans and two Democrats, potentially influencing future energy and utility decisions in the state.
- NC utilities commissioner resigns days after Duke Energy rate hike decisions WRAL
- Republican utility regulator unexpectedly resigns after Duke Energy decision News & Observer
- Van der Vaart dissents on Duke rates, data centers before resignation Carolina Journal
- NC regulators give green light to new Duke Energy electricity rates Axios
- Duke Energy customers will see higher bills starting in January after rate increases approved WCNC
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on WRAL