Jury Awards Taction $5.7 Billion in Apple Haptics Patent Dispute

2 min read
Source: Bloomberg Law News
Jury Awards Taction $5.7 Billion in Apple Haptics Patent Dispute
Photo: Bloomberg Law News
TL;DR

A federal jury in San Diego ruled that Apple infringed two haptics patents held by Taction Technology, resulting in a damages award of over $5.7 billion. The verdict covers the Taptic Engine technology used in iPhones and Apple Watches. Apple has vowed to appeal, claiming the technology is fundamentally different from Taction's patents.

Key points

  • A US District Court jury in the Southern District of California found that Apple infringed two patents owned by Taction Technology Inc. related to vibration-based tactile feedback.
  • The jury awarded damages exceeding $5.7 billion but determined that the infringement was not willful.
  • The patents in question, US Patent Nos. 10,659,885 and 10,820,117, describe tactile transducers that produce bass frequency vibrations.
  • Apple stated it strongly disagrees with the verdict and intends to appeal, arguing its Taptic Engine is distinct from Taction's technology.
  • Taction’s legal team expressed satisfaction with the outcome after a five-and-a-half-year legal battle that began with a lawsuit filed in 2021.

Background

This case has a complex procedural history. Apple initially secured a dismissal of the case in 2023, but the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed that decision in August 2025, ruling that the dismissal relied on an unwritten requirement that improperly barred Taction from using expert testimony. The litigation has been marked by intense scrutiny of funding sources, with discovery revealing that Taction received financing from entities linked to Burford Capital Ltd. Recent Apple news has focused on hardware updates and service pricing, but this legal dispute represents a significant financial exposure for the company.

Why it matters

The $5.7 billion award is a substantial financial liability for Apple and highlights the ongoing risks associated with patent litigation in the technology sector. The case also draws attention to the role of litigation funding, as Taction’s backers were identified as subsidiaries of Burford Capital. Apple’s decision to appeal suggests the dispute will continue, potentially setting precedents for haptics technology patents in consumer electronics.

What to watch

Apple has announced it will appeal the jury’s verdict. The next steps will involve the appellate process, where the company will likely argue that its Taptic Engine does not infringe on Taction’s patents. The outcome of the appeal could determine whether the $5.7 billion award stands or is reduced.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Bloomberg Law News