Affleck’s 'Animals' Casting Pivot: Why Garner Was Replaced by Washington
Ben Affleck almost cast ex-wife Jennifer Garner as his on-screen partner in the Netflix thriller 'Animals,' but the project’s shifting timeline and concerns about audience perception led to a final swap. After Matt Damon dropped out to work with Christopher Nolan, Affleck took the lead role. Garner ultimately declined the part, citing 'baggage' from their divorce, resulting in Kerry Washington stepping in. The film premieres on October 9.
Key points
- Affleck initially cast Garner for the role of Abigail while Matt Damon was set to star as Mark Kimball.
- Affleck paused production after learning Spike Lee was developing a similar kidnapping thriller, 'Highest 2 Lowest.'
- Damon exited the project to join Christopher Nolan’s 'The Odyssey,' prompting Affleck to take the lead role.
- Garner declined the role after Affleck joined, stating they did not want to bring 'baggage' to the audience.
- Kerry Washington was cast as Abigail after Affleck and Washington connected during the 2023 Hollywood strikes.
Background
Affleck and Garner divorced in 2015 after a 14-year marriage. Garner has previously discussed the financial and career challenges she faced following their split, including co-founding the baby-food brand Once Upon a Farm. Affleck and Garner share three children and maintain a cooperative co-parenting relationship, which Affleck noted could have facilitated a shared filming schedule.
How outlets are covering it
Deadline and TheWrap highlight the logistical and professional reasons for the casting change, emphasizing Affleck’s desire to coordinate schedules around their custody arrangement. The Daily Beast focuses on the 'baggage' aspect, framing Garner’s decision as a strategic move to avoid public scrutiny. All sources agree that Affleck and Garner remain on good terms, with Affleck expressing a desire to work with her in the future.
Why it matters
The casting decision illustrates how personal history and industry timing can influence high-profile film projects. It also highlights the competitive landscape for similar genres, as Affleck paused production to avoid direct competition with Spike Lee’s 'Highest 2 Lowest.'
What to watch
The film 'Animals' is set to premiere on Netflix on October 9, 2026, with a limited theatrical release. It stars Affleck, Kerry Washington, Gillian Anderson, and Steven Yeun.
- Ben Affleck Nearly Cast Ex Jennifer Garner As His Wife In ‘Animals’: “You Just Get Baggage” Deadline
- Ben Affleck Almost Cast Ex-Wife Jennifer Garner in His Netflix Film 'Animals': 'We Don't Want to Do That' TheWrap
- Jennifer Garner & Ben Affleck Almost Reunited on Screen After 23 Years Yahoo
- A-Lister Reveals Why He Bailed on Casting Ex at Last Minute The Daily Beast
- Ben Affleck Almost Cast Ex-Wife Jennifer Garner In 'Animals' Variety
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Deadline