Chastain's Horror Outperforms Sorkin's Facebook Drama in Box Office Clash
Universal's 'Other Mommy' dominated the weekend with $27.5 million, while Aaron Sorkin's 'The Social Reckoning' underperformed with $5.5 million. Despite poor reviews, the horror film's low budget and Halloween timing drove strong returns, whereas the drama struggled with audience demographics and high production costs.
Key points
- 'Other Mommy' earned $27.5 million domestically and $45.19 million globally against an $18 million budget.
- 'The Social Reckoning' opened to $5.5 million, far below its $30 million budget and the $22 million debut of its 2010 predecessor.
- Both films received mixed reviews, but 'Other Mommy' benefited from strong Halloween demand and a lower price point.
- Holdovers like 'Verity' and 'Resident Evil' maintained strong positions, with 'Resident Evil' nearing $300 million globally.
Background
The 2010 film 'The Social Network' earned $224 million globally and won four Oscars. 'The Social Reckoning' was marketed as a 'companion piece' rather than a sequel to distance it from the original's success. Previous archive coverage noted that 'Other Mommy' was projected to open at $28 million despite poor critical reception, while 'The Social Reckoning' was expected to debut at $6 million.
How outlets are covering it
Variety and Deadline both highlight the stark contrast between the two new releases, noting that 'Other Mommy' exceeded expectations despite a 19% Rotten Tomatoes score and a D+ CinemaScore. Variety emphasizes the financial safety of the horror genre, while Deadline points out the strong Friday preview numbers for 'Other Mommy' and the weak previews for 'The Social Reckoning.' The Daily Beast offers a positive critical take on 'Other Mommy,' praising Jessica Chastain's performance and the film's momentum, contrasting with the negative reviews cited by Variety and Deadline. All sources agree that 'The Social Reckoning' failed to attract a broad audience, with Variety noting its reliance on older male demographics and Deadline highlighting its strong performance on the coasts but weak overall reach.
Why it matters
The weekend results underscore the continued dominance of horror films in the Halloween season and the challenges faced by high-budget dramas with niche audiences. 'Other Mommy's' success despite poor reviews suggests that genre and timing can outweigh critical reception, while 'The Social Reckoning's' underperformance raises questions about the viability of corporate intrigue films in the current theatrical landscape.
What to watch
Upcoming releases like Paramount's 'Street Fighter,' Disney's 'Whalefall,' and Warner Bros.' 'Clayface' are expected to impact the box office in the coming weeks. 'The Social Reckoning' and 'Other Mommy' will face significant declines in their second weekends, with 'Other Mommy' expected to drop sharply due to poor word-of-mouth. Specialty releases like 'Musk,' 'Misty Green,' and 'Fjord' will test their commercial appeal as they expand nationwide.
- ‘The Social Reckoning’ Flops With $5.5 Million Debut, ‘Other Mommy’ Tops Box Office With $27.5 Million Variety
- ‘Other Mommy’ Review: Parent, Trap The New York Times
- Jessica Chastain's horror movie 'Other Mommy' is filled with jump scares. But is it actually scary? Yahoo
- Box Office: 'Other Mommy' Leads In Opening, 'The Social Reckoning' Ghosted Deadline
- ‘Other Mommy’: Jessica Chastain’s Horror Tour de Force Is Absolutely Insane The Daily Beast
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Variety