Andrew Scott's 'Elsinore' Revives Ian Charleson's Final Hamlet Amid Mixed Critical Reception
Simon Stone's drama 'Elsinore' premieres at Telluride, starring Andrew Scott as the late actor Ian Charleson. The film chronicles Charleson's final 1989 National Theatre performance of Hamlet while battling AIDS. Critics praise Scott's performance but debate the film's emotional execution and historical accuracy.
Key points
- Andrew Scott portrays Ian Charleson, who died of AIDS in 1990 at age 40, in the drama 'Elsinore'.
- The film depicts Charleson's 24-performance run as Hamlet at the National Theatre in 1989, replacing Daniel Day-Lewis.
- Olivia Colman plays Dr. Margaret Johnson, a pioneer in HIV treatment, while Billie Piper plays Charleson's friend Patsy Pollock.
- The film received a wide release date of November 20, 2026, distributed by Focus Features in North America.
- Critics are divided: some call Scott's performance 'shattering' and 'heartbreaking,' while others criticize the film's editing and 'awards-bait' tropes.
Background
Our archive notes that Focus Features acquired 'Elsinore' in July 2026 for a fall release. The film was part of the Telluride 2026 lineup, which was positioned as an Oscar bellwether. Previous coverage highlighted the film's focus on Charleson's courage and the impact of his final performance.
How outlets are covering it
The Hollywood Reporter and Deadline offer glowing reviews, with David Rooney calling Scott's performance 'shattering' and Pete Hammond describing it as 'thrilling.' Both outlets emphasize the film's emotional power and its tribute to the theater. In contrast, IndieWire's Ryan Lattanzio is more critical, arguing that while Scott's performance is 'mesmerizing,' the film's editing and conventional storytelling 'dull' the greatness of the role. Lattanzio criticizes the film for relying on 'AIDS-movie awards-bait clichés' and failing to let the audience 'sink in' to the material. The Guardian provides historical context, quoting director Richard Eyre on Charleson's determination and the secrecy surrounding his illness. All sources agree on the factual details of Charleson's 1989 Hamlet run and his subsequent death, but differ significantly on the artistic merit of Stone's direction and Beresford's screenplay.
Why it matters
The film highlights the intersection of queer history, theater, and the AIDS crisis in the late 1980s. It also signals a potential Best Actor push for Andrew Scott, with industry insiders and critics heavily tipping him for an Oscar nomination. The debate over the film's execution reflects broader discussions about how to portray historical trauma and illness in cinema without resorting to exploitative tropes.
What to watch
The film is scheduled for a wide release on November 20, 2026. The outcome of the critical reception and audience response will likely determine its trajectory in the upcoming awards season, particularly for the Best Actor category.
- ‘Elsinore’ Review: Andrew Scott Is Shattering as British Actor Ian Charleson, Throwing Himself Into Playing Hamlet While Succumbing to AIDS The Hollywood Reporter
- ‘Like a tired boxer, battered by applause’: as Andrew Scott’s biopic premieres, Richard Eyre remembers Ian Charleson’s superb, near-death Hamlet The Guardian
- 'Elsinore' Review: Andrew Scott Brilliant In Story Of Ian Charleson Deadline
- 'Elsinore' Movie Review: Andrew Scott Towers Over Awards Bait Cliches IndieWire
- ‘Elsinore’ Review: Andrew Scott Is Powerfully Moving as Ian Charleson, the ‘Chariots of Fire’ Star Who Played Hamlet While Ravaged by AIDS Variety
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Hollywood Reporter