New Mexico judge dismisses Busfield child abuse charges over prosecutorial errors
A New Mexico judge dismissed child sexual abuse charges against actor Timothy Busfield on October 16, citing prosecutorial misconduct. Judge Joseph Montano ruled that the prosecutor failed to act impartially by improperly instructing the grand jury and withholding requested witnesses. Busfield, who has denied the allegations, had been indicted in February on four counts related to incidents with minor twins during his work on 'The Cleaning Lady.' His wife, Melissa Gilbert, publicly celebrated the ruling, while the state retains the right to refile charges.
Key points
- Judge Joseph Montano granted Busfield's motion to dismiss the indictment on October 16, 2026.
- The ruling cited the prosecutor's failure to properly instruct grand jurors on calling witnesses and withholding requested testimony.
- Busfield was indicted in February on four counts of criminal sexual contact of a child, stemming from alleged incidents with two minor twins.
- Melissa Gilbert posted a Shakespeare quote on Instagram and shared news of the dismissal, maintaining her belief in her husband's innocence.
- The state retains the right to refile charges, and prosecutors are currently evaluating next steps.
Background
Busfield, 69, turned himself in in January 2026 after allegations of unlawful sexual conduct with twin 11-year-old actors from the TV series 'The Cleaning Lady.' He pleaded not guilty in February, with a trial originally scheduled for May 2027. His wife, Melissa Gilbert, had previously described the case as the 'most traumatizing experience of our lives' and expressed confidence in his exoneration.
How outlets are covering it
USA TODAY emphasized the emotional response of Melissa Gilbert, highlighting her public celebration and long-standing defense of her husband's innocence. The New York Times focused on the legal procedural failures, detailing Judge Montano's written order that the prosecutor failed to act in a fair and impartial manner by improperly instructing the grand jury. Both outlets agreed on the dismissal but differed in emphasis, with USA TODAY focusing on the personal impact and NYT on the legal mechanics.
Why it matters
The dismissal highlights the importance of procedural fairness in grand jury proceedings and the potential for prosecutorial misconduct to undermine criminal cases. It also underscores the ongoing public scrutiny of high-profile cases involving celebrities and the impact of legal outcomes on personal and professional reputations.
What to watch
Prosecutors in New Mexico are evaluating their next steps, including the possibility of refiling charges. Busfield's legal team is expected to continue advocating for his exoneration, while Gilbert may further publicize the dismissal. The case may also face further legal challenges or appeals depending on the state's decision.
- Melissa Gilbert reacts after sex abuse case dismissed against husband Timothy Busfield USA Today
- Judge Dismisses Child Sexual Abuse Charges Against Timothy Busfield The New York Times
- New Mexico judge tosses charges against actor Timothy Busfield, citing prosecutor misconduct The Boston Globe
- Judge drops case against Timothy Busfield Albuquerque Journal
- Judge dismisses sexual abuse case against East Lansing native Timothy Busfield Lansing State Journal
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on USA Today