D.C. Teen Held Without Bond After Accused of Killing Twin Brother in Basement Shooting

Jamari Young, 16, was held without bond after being charged as an adult with second-degree murder for the fatal shooting of his identical twin, Jabrell Young, in their Northeast D.C. home. While prosecutors allege the death resulted from an argument over personal belongings, the family insists the shooting was an accidental discharge during a struggle. Investigators have not recovered the weapon used, though a separate gun linked to a prior homicide was found nearby.
Key points
- Jamari Young was arrested by the Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task Force on Nov. 19 and ordered held without bond in D.C. Superior Court.
- Jabrell Young died from two gunshot wounds to the chest in the basement of their home on Oct. 25, 2026.
- Court documents allege the shooting occurred during a tussle after Jabrell entered Jamari's room and touched his belongings.
- The mother, Chantel Poe, maintains the shooting was an accident and that her sons were inseparable best friends.
- Police recovered .45-caliber shell casings but have not found the weapon used in the fatal shooting.
Background
This case follows a pattern of high-profile juvenile homicide cases in the region, such as the recent Boulder shooting involving a university student, where bond decisions and the classification of intent (accidental vs. malicious) are central to public discourse. The current case highlights the tension between prosecutorial charges and family narratives in domestic incidents involving minors.
How outlets are covering it
FOX 5 DC and Fox News Digital emphasize the legal proceedings, noting Jamari is charged as an adult and held without bond, while highlighting the mother’s claims of harassment and mistreatment by law enforcement. NBC4 Washington focuses on the family’s narrative, quoting the mother’s assertion that the shooting was an accident and that Jamari was terrified. All sources agree on the basic facts of the Oct. 25 shooting and the Nov. 19 arrest, but differ in emphasis: Fox outlets stress the formal charges and bond status, while NBC4 centers the emotional plea from the family and the lack of recovered evidence linking the found 9mm pistol to the fatal shooting.
Why it matters
The case underscores the complexities of prosecuting juveniles for fatal shootings where intent is disputed. The failure to recover the weapon used in the shooting and the discovery of an unrelated firearm linked to a prior homicide complicate the investigation. Additionally, the family’s allegations of being treated as suspects rather than grieving relatives raise questions about police conduct in high-profile domestic cases.
What to watch
Jamari Young’s next court appearance is scheduled for next month. Investigators continue to seek information on where Jamari went after the shooting and whether he received assistance while missing. The family has launched a GoFundMe campaign to support legal defense costs.
- DC teen held without bond in twin brother's deadly shooting FOX 5 DC
- 16-year-old shot twin brother to death during argument, court docs say WUSA9
- DC 16-year-old accidentally killed his twin and ‘best friend,' mother says NBC4 Washington
- Twin teens were ‘thick as thieves.’ Now one’s accused of killing the other. The Washington Post
- Teen accused of fatally shooting identical twin brother after fight about touching his belongings Fox News
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on FOX 5 DC