Forensic expert challenges Epstein suicide ruling, citing signs of homicide

A forensic expert claims Jeffrey Epstein was likely murdered, contradicting the 2019 suicide ruling. The NYC Medical Examiner stands by its original determination. The new analysis cites injuries inconsistent with hanging, but has not been peer-reviewed.
Key points
- Dr. Michael Freeman, a forensic medicine expert, presented findings in London on Monday arguing Epstein was strangled from behind, not hanged by suicide.
- Freeman claims Epstein’s body showed signs of assault, including a deep hemorrhage in the left shoulder, facial injuries, and fingernail marks above the ligature mark.
- The NYC Office of the Chief Medical Examiner reaffirmed its 2019 determination that Epstein died by suicide via hanging, stating there was no evidence of defensive wounds.
- Freeman’s analysis is based on autopsy files and photos provided by Epstein’s brother, Mark Epstein, and has not been peer-reviewed or accepted by academic journals.
- A 2023 Justice Department report previously cited serious failures in the investigation, including staffing shortages and surveillance issues, but maintained the suicide finding.
Background
Jeffrey Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York City on August 10, 2019, while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges. The official cause of death was ruled suicide by hanging. Public skepticism has persisted, fueled by a 2020 review by forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden and recent document releases. In October 2026, a Hawaii medical examiner similarly ruled a flight attendant’s death a suicide despite family claims of homicide, highlighting ongoing debates over custody and in-custody death determinations. Additionally, in October 2026, a judge ordered the reinstatement of Maurene Comey, a former prosecutor who worked on the Epstein case, after ruling her firing unlawful.
How outlets are covering it
CNN and CBS News report that Dr. Michael Freeman, along with Anders Eriksson and Itiel Dror, concluded Epstein was likely killed based on a biomechanical reconstruction and review of autopsy photos. They emphasize injuries Freeman claims are inconsistent with suicidal hanging, such as a second ligature mark and shoulder hemorrhage. Newsweek notes that Freeman’s findings are not peer-reviewed and that the NYC Medical Examiner stands by its original ruling. The BBC highlights that Freeman, who has served as an expert in other high-profile custody deaths, states he does not know who killed Epstein but believes the evidence points to homicide. All sources agree that the NYC Medical Examiner’s office has not revised its 2019 determination, despite the new analysis. The House Oversight Committee recently released a report criticizing the federal government’s handling of the Epstein investigation, recommending further scrutiny.
Why it matters
This new forensic analysis reignites public debate over the circumstances of Epstein’s death and the integrity of the original investigation. It underscores ongoing questions about accountability in custody deaths and the reliability of medical examiner determinations in high-profile cases. The findings may influence future reviews of similar cases and highlight the need for transparent, peer-reviewed forensic evaluations in custody deaths.
What to watch
Freeman plans to resubmit his findings to an academic journal after initial rejection. The NYC Medical Examiner’s office has declined to comment further on Freeman’s analysis. The House Oversight Committee has recommended the Justice Department reinterview key witnesses and investigate allegations involving Epstein’s associates. No official investigation into Freeman’s claims has been announced by federal authorities.
- Forensic expert says Epstein was likely killed, but NYC medical examiner stands by suicide ruling CNN
- Forensics Expert Lists Reasons He Believes Epstein’s Death May Be Homicide Newsweek
- Challenging Consensus, Scientist Says Photos Show Epstein Was Killed The New York Times
- Jeffrey Epstein's death may not have been suicide, new analysis by leading forensics expert suggests CBS News
- Forensic expert says his analysis of autopsy photos suggests Epstein was killed BBC
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on CNN