Former Titans scout Blaise Taylor sentenced to consecutive life terms for poisoning girlfriend and unborn child

Key points

• Blaise Taylor was convicted on four counts of felony murder on July 1, 2026, for poisoning his girlfriend Jade Benning and their unborn child.
• Judge Steve Dozier sentenced Taylor to two consecutive life terms on September 9, 2026, at the Justice A. Birch Building in Nashville.
• The defense submitted 87 character letters, but prosecutors pointed out that none of the letters mentioned the victims or the crime.
• Taylor’s attorney, Letitia Quinones-Hollins, stated the defense plans to appeal the verdict, calling the trial flawed.
• Taylor is currently held at the Davidson County Jail and will be transferred to a state prison following the sentencing hearing.

Background

This case follows the July 1 conviction of Blaise Taylor, a former scout for the Tennessee Titans, on charges of poisoning his girlfriend and unborn child. The sentencing hearing on September 9 marked the final stage of the trial process, with the judge determining whether the life sentences would run concurrently or consecutively. The case has drawn attention due to Taylor’s previous connection to the NFL and the stark contrast between the character letters submitted by the defense and the prosecution’s emphasis on the victims.

How outlets are covering it

NBC Sports and News Channel 5 Nashville both reported on the consecutive life sentences, with NBC Sports highlighting the 87 character letters and the prosecution’s response. WZTV confirmed the sentencing but did not provide as much detail on the character letters. Yahoo’s coverage emphasized the judge’s lack of mercy, aligning with the prosecution’s stance. All sources agree on the core facts of the conviction and sentencing, but differ in their emphasis on the character letters and the defense’s plans to appeal.

Why it matters

The case highlights the severe consequences of violent crimes and the legal process in Tennessee. It also raises questions about the role of character evidence in criminal trials and the effectiveness of appeals in overturning convictions. The involvement of a former NFL scout adds a layer of public interest and scrutiny to the case.

What to watch

Taylor’s legal team plans to appeal the verdict, potentially seeking a new trial or the dismissal of charges. The outcome of the appeal will determine whether Taylor remains in custody for the rest of his life or if the case is reopened. The transfer to a state prison is expected to occur soon after the sentencing hearing.