Four charged in 2023 Scott Spivey road rage killing; bonds set after arraignment

Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams have been charged with murder in the 2023 shooting death of Scott Spivey, while two former Horry County police officers face charges for misconduct in the investigation. The case, which stalled for three years, gained momentum after the victim's sister uncovered hidden recordings and a judge denied stand-your-ground immunity. All four defendants appeared in court on November 19, 2026, where bonds were set, with the family requesting denial of release for the shooters.
Key points
- Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams were indicted on murder and weapon possession charges for the September 9, 2023, death of Scott Spivey in Horry County, South Carolina.
- Former Horry County Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland and former Sergeant Paul Vescovi were charged with misconduct in office, obstruction of justice, and conspiracy, alleging they compromised the investigation.
- Boyd's bond was set at $110,000, Williams' at $100,000, and the two officers at $10,000 each; all were processed at the J. Reuben Long Detention Center.
- The case advanced after the victim's sister, Jennifer Spivey Foley, discovered phone recordings from Boyd that contradicted his self-defense claim, which were later published by The Wall Street Journal.
- A circuit court judge denied Boyd and Williams stand-your-ground immunity in February 2026, prompting a grand jury review that resulted in the recent indictments.
Background
Scott Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster, was shot during a car chase on Highway 9 in Horry County in September 2023. Local prosecutors initially declined to charge the suspects, and the South Carolina Attorney General's office also declined prosecution in 2024 and 2025, citing insufficient evidence or the applicability of stand-your-ground laws. The Spivey family pursued a wrongful death lawsuit, leading to a civil hearing in February 2026 where a judge questioned the credibility of the defendants' self-defense claims. This legal pressure eventually led to the grand jury indictments in November 2026.
How outlets are covering it
Fox News emphasizes the role of the victim's sister in uncovering hidden recordings that undermined the self-defense narrative, highlighting the family's long fight for justice. WMBF and WBTW focus on the specific charges against the former police officers, detailing body-camera footage and phone calls that suggest the investigation was mishandled. Defense attorneys, as reported by WBTW and WMBF, argue that Spivey was the aggressor, was intoxicated, and that the officers were merely trying to support a friend or learn about the situation, not engaging in a grand conspiracy. The Spivey family, represented by their attorney, maintains that the shooting was not justified and that the system failed to investigate the death properly until external pressure was applied.
Why it matters
The case highlights issues with police accountability and the application of stand-your-ground laws in South Carolina. The involvement of former high-ranking police officers in the investigation raises questions about the integrity of the criminal justice system and the potential for misconduct in handling fatal incidents. The lengthy delay in charging the suspects, despite new evidence, underscores the challenges victims' families face in seeking justice through the legal system.
What to watch
The defendants will continue to face legal proceedings as the case moves through the court system. The Spivey family has requested a competency evaluation for Boyd and is concerned about witness tampering. The outcome of the criminal trial will determine the final accountability for the shooting and the alleged misconduct by the former police officers.
- ‘Stand your ground’ claim falters in road rage killing as men charged with murder, ex-cops face accusations Fox News
- Bond set for all 4 indicted in Scott Spivey shooting case arraignment WPDE
- Former Horry County deputy chief, sergeant charged in Scott Spivey investigation WMBF
- 2 former Horry County police officers charged in Scott Spivey case WBTW
- Two shooters of Scott Spivey now face murder charges. Here’s what we know Myrtle Beach Sun News
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Fox News