DOJ Abandons Alaska Senate Suit After Peltola Victory

3 min read
Source: The Hill
DOJ Abandons Alaska Senate Suit After Peltola Victory
Photo: The Hill
TL;DR

The U.S. Department of Justice has moved to dismiss its lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate race results. The legal challenge, ordered by President Trump, aimed to prevent Democrat Mary Peltola from taking office by citing potential voter confusion caused by a third-party candidate sharing the incumbent’s name. With Peltola having won the election, the administration argued the case was moot, effectively conceding the outcome.

Key points

  • The Justice Department filed documents on Thursday asking the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare its lawsuit moot and vacate the lower court’s dismissal order.
  • The suit sought to block the certification of Peltola’s victory, arguing that voters might have confused her with incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan due to a third candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who shared the senator’s name.
  • Peltola won the race, securing a majority of votes even when the votes for the two candidates named Sullivan were combined, according to Decision Desk HQ and the Associated Press.
  • The New York Times previously reported that Peltola’s campaign and national Democrats were involved in recruiting the third candidate, a claim Peltola denied. Federal probes into the matter were launched but did not stop the election.
  • Alaska state officials, controlled by Republicans, called the federal lawsuit 'meritless' and supported its dismissal, noting that the state Supreme Court had already ruled the third candidate’s ballot placement legal.

Background

The DOJ filed the lawsuit in late October, shortly after the New York Times reported on the recruitment of the third candidate. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on November 1, ruling that the federal government lacked standing to intervene in state election certification. This is the second high-profile election lawsuit the DOJ has dropped since the November 3 elections, following a similar dismissal in California regarding ballot counting.

How outlets are covering it

The Hill and CBS News frame the move as a concession by the Trump administration after a 'much-criticized gambit' failed to prevent Peltola’s victory. The New York Times emphasizes the abandonment of a legal maneuver that threatened to block a Democratic win, noting the administration’s prior argument that voter confusion could invalidate the result. WRAL highlights that the move ends a legal challenge that was opposed by both the Peltola campaign and Alaska state officials, who deemed the federal intervention legally baseless. All sources agree that the case is now moot due to the election outcome, though they differ on the emphasis: some focus on the political implications for the Senate majority, while others focus on the legal standing issues raised by Judge Gleason.

Why it matters

The dismissal removes the final legal barrier to Peltola’s certification as the 56th Democratic senator, solidifying the party’s control of the Senate. It also marks a significant retreat by the federal government from intervening in state election certification processes, a move that had drawn criticism from legal experts and state officials for lacking constitutional authority. The case underscores the tensions between federal election integrity claims and state sovereignty in close races.

What to watch

Peltola is expected to be certified as the U.S. Senator from Alaska, assuming no further legal challenges arise. The federal probes into the recruitment of the third candidate may continue, but they are unlikely to impact the election outcome. The DOJ’s decision to vacate the lower court’s dismissal order may have implications for future federal interventions in state elections, though the immediate focus will shift to Peltola’s confirmation and the broader Senate majority.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Hill