DOJ expands Alaska election probe to 200 subpoenas as Peltola certified winner

The U.S. Justice Department has issued over 200 subpoenas in a criminal investigation into the 2026 Alaska Senate race, focusing on allegations that Democratic operatives recruited a second candidate named Dan Sullivan to confuse voters. Democrat Mary Peltola was officially certified as the winner on November 17, defeating incumbent Republican Dan S. Sullivan by approximately 12,400 votes. The probe, which spans multiple states and targets several individuals including attorney Marc Elias, continues despite the election results. Peltola and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee deny any wrongdoing, while voting data suggests the 'decoy' candidate did not significantly siphon Republican support.
Key points
- The DOJ has issued more than 200 subpoenas in a criminal probe into the Alaska Senate race, up from 40 issued in late October.
- Mary Peltola was certified as the winner on November 17, securing 144,302 votes compared to Dan S. Sullivan's 131,844.
- The investigation targets allegations that Democrats recruited Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher, to run as a spoiler candidate to confuse voters.
- Prominent Democratic attorney Marc Elias, who represents the Peltola campaign, received a criminal target letter from the DOJ.
- The probe spans multiple states and involves multiple criminal targets, according to law enforcement sources.
Background
The controversy began in October 2026 when The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign aides and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee participated in a 'ballot composition project' to recruit a second Dan Sullivan. The DOJ initially issued 40 subpoenas and a civil lawsuit in late October, which was dismissed by a federal judge. President Trump called for Peltola to drop out and labeled the scheme a 'rigged' election. Peltola, a former state lawmaker and the first Alaska Native elected to Congress in 2022, denied knowledge of the alleged scheme. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg, Alaska, ran a low-profile campaign raising $35,556 and won 4,760 votes.
How outlets are covering it
Fox News emphasizes the scale of the DOJ's criminal probe, highlighting the 200 subpoenas and the involvement of multiple states and targets. The outlet frames the investigation as a response to a 'outrageous election cheating scandal' and notes that Peltola's victory does not halt the criminal case. The New York Times focuses on the election outcome, noting that Peltola's victory margin exceeded the votes cast for the 'decoy' candidate, suggesting the alleged scheme may not have been decisive. BBC Verify analyzes ranked-choice voting data, finding that 38% of voters who chose Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. first left their second choice blank, and that nearly twice as many of these voters ranked Peltola second compared to Dan S. Sullivan. This data challenges the claim that Republican voters were confused. AP News contextualizes the Alaska result within the broader Democratic midterm sweep, noting that Peltola's win gives Democrats a 56-44 Senate majority, their largest gain in nearly 70 years.
Why it matters
The DOJ's expansion of the Alaska probe to 200 subpoenas signals a significant federal effort to investigate alleged election interference, potentially setting precedents for federal involvement in state election disputes. The outcome of the criminal investigation could impact the political careers of key Democratic figures, including Marc Elias, and influence future election integrity laws. The case also highlights tensions between federal and state authorities over election administration and the legal boundaries of recruiting spoiler candidates. Additionally, the Alaska result is pivotal for the balance of power in the U.S. Senate, with Democrats securing their largest midterm gain in decades.
What to watch
The DOJ will continue its criminal investigation, potentially leading to charges against individuals involved in the alleged 'ballot composition project.' Peltola and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee are expected to respond to the subpoenas and target letters. The Senate will convene in January with a 56-44 Democratic majority, and the Alaska result may influence future federal election integrity legislation. Legal experts will continue to debate the jurisdiction and legality of the DOJ's actions in state election matters.
- Hundreds of subpoenas fly in DOJ’s ‘Decoy Dan’ probe as Democrat Peltola declared winner in Alaska Fox News
- Fish and High Prices: How Mary Peltola Triumphed in Alaska’s Senate Race The New York Times
- Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does data show? BBC
- Democrats flipped 9 US Senate seats — the most in almost 70 years AP News
- Two weeks later, Senate vote count is complete, the House nearly finished The Washington Post
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Fox News