Mullin defends ICE shooting of father in NYC as state officials demand halt to operations
DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin defended an ICE agent who shot 28-year-old Oscar Bergal in New York City on Thursday, calling the victim a 'threat to our community.' While DHS claims Bergal attempted to flee and weaponize his vehicle, New York officials and the victim's attorneys dispute the account, demanding an independent investigation and the release of body camera footage.
Key points
- Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin stated that Oscar Bergal, a Dominican national, was one of 'the worst of the worst' and that the shooting occurred after he refused lawful orders and accelerated his vehicle into ICE cars.
- The shooting took place in the Marble Hill neighborhood of New York City on October 8, 2026, while Bergal's 5-year-old son was in the back seat of the car; the child was not physically injured but was described as traumatized.
- New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul condemned the incident, with Mamdani calling ICE 'rotten to its core' and Hochul demanding a cessation of ICE activities in the state.
- DHS officials claim they did not know the child was in the vehicle when the agent fired, while a nearby witness told CBS News the car was driving away from agents, contradicting the federal account of a vehicle assault.
- Bergal, who has a prior grand larceny conviction and alleged gang ties, remains in federal custody with a bullet still in his neck; his attorneys are petitioning for his release, claiming he was arrested without a valid warrant.
Background
This incident follows a pattern of ICE enforcement controversies in 2026, including a September shooting in Austin, Texas, where a Venezuelan national was shot by an ICE officer and subsequently detained with a bullet lodged in his body. That earlier case highlighted ongoing disputes between federal agencies and local officials regarding evidence transparency and the medical care of shooting victims.
How outlets are covering it
DHS and ICE officials, including Mullin and ICE spokesperson Marcos Charles, framed the shooting as a necessary response to a violent suspect who 'weaponized his vehicle' and refused to comply with orders. In contrast, New York officials, including Mayor Mamdani and Governor Hochul, characterized the action as an act of terror and 'impunity,' demanding the immediate release of the victim and a halt to all ICE operations in the state. CBS News reported conflicting accounts from a local witness who stated the vehicle was driving away, while Fox News emphasized the victim's criminal history and gang associations to support the federal narrative.
Why it matters
The incident has intensified the national debate over immigration enforcement tactics and the use of deadly force by federal agents in urban areas. The clash between federal and state authorities over jurisdiction and the transparency of body camera footage highlights the deepening political polarization surrounding ICE operations and the legal rights of individuals targeted by federal enforcement.
What to watch
A federal judge is expected to rule on the petition for Bergal's release from federal custody. New York officials are pressing for the public release of body camera footage to establish the facts of the shooting, while the Bronx District Attorney's office has stated it is conducting a thorough investigation into the incident.
- DHS chief defends New York ICE shooting, calling victim one of ‘the worst of the worst’ Politico
- Mamdani demands Trump release illegal immigrant shot by ICE agent as protests erupt in the Bronx Fox News
- NYPD body camera footage shows aftermath of ICE agent shooting of man in Marble Hill CBS News
- Mullin Criticizes Sanctuary City Policies After ICE Shooting in New York: Live Updates The New York Times
- ICE official says officers shot a man in New York because they believed they were in danger PBS
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Politico