Texas AG Paxton drops CAIR lawsuit after election defeat

4 min read
Source: The Texas Tribune
Texas AG Paxton drops CAIR lawsuit after election defeat
Photo: The Texas Tribune
TL;DR

Outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has withdrawn a lawsuit seeking to ban the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) from operating in the state. The case, filed in February 2026, alleged CAIR was a foreign terrorist organization working with the Muslim Brotherhood. The dismissal follows Paxton’s loss in the U.S. Senate race and a broader trend of his office dropping lawsuits after the midterm elections. Incoming Governor Gina Hinojosa has pledged to remove the state’s terrorist designation of CAIR, though the legal case was dismissed without prejudice, leaving the door open for future action.

Key points

  • Paxton’s office filed a notice of nonsuit on Monday, voiding the lawsuit filed in February 2026.
  • The suit sought to declare CAIR and its Texas chapters foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organizations.
  • The lawsuit alleged CAIR collaborated with the Muslim Brotherhood to undermine government authority and establish Sharia law.
  • CAIR rejected the allegations, stating the suit was politically motivated to punish its opposition to Israel’s war in Gaza.
  • Gov. Greg Abbott previously designated CAIR a foreign terrorist organization and urged Paxton to sue.
  • Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa has promised to remove the terrorist designation upon taking office.

Background

This development follows a series of legal withdrawals by Paxton’s office since the midterm elections. In November 2026, AG-elect Nathan Johnson announced he would not pursue lawsuits against out-of-state abortion pill providers, signaling a shift from Paxton’s aggressive litigation strategy. Earlier in October, Paxton had sued OpenAI over AI safety concerns, aligning with other states. The political landscape shifted significantly after Paxton lost his U.S. Senate bid to Democrat James Talarico, and Gov. Abbott was swept out of office in a blue wave. Paxton also finalized his divorce from state Sen. Angela Paxton in November 2026, days after his Senate defeat, concluding a 38-year marriage that had become a central issue in the election.

How outlets are covering it

The Texas Tribune and KERA News both report that Paxton’s office filed a notice of nonsuit, effectively ending the lawsuit. The Texas Tribune emphasizes the political context, noting the dismissal came nearly two weeks after Paxton’s Senate loss and Abbott’s defeat. KERA highlights CAIR’s desire for unity under the new administration, quoting CAIR-Dallas executive director Mustafaa Carroll. Click2Houston focuses on the legal nuance, noting that the dismissal was without prejudice, leaving the door open for the state to refile. All sources agree that the lawsuit was filed in February 2026 and sought to ban CAIR from Texas. The Texas Tribune and Click2Houston both note that Abbott’s designation of CAIR as a foreign terrorist organization remains in effect, but Hinojosa has pledged to reverse it. KERA notes that CAIR denies Abbott’s claims that it was a front group for Hamas. The sources differ in emphasis: The Texas Tribune focuses on the political rejection of anti-Muslim bigotry, KERA on CAIR’s desire for peace, and Click2Houston on the legal implications of the dismissal.

Why it matters

The dismissal of the CAIR lawsuit marks a significant shift in Texas’s legal and political stance toward Muslim civil rights groups. It reflects the broader impact of the midterm elections, where voters rejected anti-Islam campaigns. The move also signals a potential change in enforcement priorities under the new administration, with Hinojosa pledging to remove the terrorist designation. However, the dismissal without prejudice means the legal threat is not entirely gone, and the state could potentially refile. The case also highlights the tension between state and federal authorities, as Abbott’s designation remains in effect despite the lawsuit’s dismissal. The development is part of a larger trend of Paxton’s office dropping lawsuits, suggesting a shift in the state’s legal strategy following the election.

What to watch

The next steps include Hinojosa’s removal of the terrorist designation upon taking office. CAIR may seek to address the remaining designation and any potential legal challenges. The state could potentially refile the lawsuit, given the dismissal was without prejudice. The broader implications for Texas’s legal strategy and its relationship with Muslim civil rights groups will depend on the new administration’s actions. The case also sets a precedent for how Texas handles similar legal challenges in the future.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Texas Tribune