Binding of Isaac Update Faces Review Bomb After AI Music Discovery in GTA 6 Mode

3 min read
Source: Kotaku
Binding of Isaac Update Faces Review Bomb After AI Music Discovery in GTA 6 Mode
Photo: Kotaku
TL;DR

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ faced a severe backlash after players discovered AI-generated music in a new GTA 6-themed mode. Creator Edmund McMillen was unaware of the inclusion, and Nicalis has not yet explained how the tracks were added. The controversy, combined with pre-existing quality issues, caused the game’s Steam rating to plummet to 9% positive.

Key points

  • A free update for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ on PC and consoles included a special 'Vice City' mode timed with the launch of Grand Theft Auto 6.
  • Players identified metadata in the mode’s audio files indicating the music was generated using Suno, an AI tool, despite no official disclosure.
  • Edmund McMillen, the game’s creator, stated he was unaware of the AI usage and is working to remove the tracks.
  • The Steam page for the expansion received a review bomb, dropping its positive rating to 9% due to the AI issue and ongoing technical problems.
  • Nicalis, the publisher and co-developer, has not yet issued a formal explanation or taken responsibility for the inclusion of AI-generated assets.

Background

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ launched as a free update in 2024 on PC and arrived on consoles in November 2026. The expansion introduced online co-op, quality-of-life improvements, and item rebalancing. The game has a long history of community engagement, with McMillen noting that player feedback significantly influenced features like in-game item descriptions. The recent controversy follows a period of growing complaints about bugs and quality control in the expansion.

How outlets are covering it

Kotaku and GoNintendo report that the AI music discovery triggered immediate outrage, with fans criticizing Nicalis for cutting corners. Kotaku highlights that the Steam rating dropped to 9% positive, while GoNintendo notes McMillen’s surprise and his efforts to remove the content. iXBT.games emphasizes that the review bomb was also fueled by pre-existing issues with co-op stability and save data risks, suggesting the AI music was the final straw for a frustrated player base. Cubed3 provides background on McMillen’s design philosophy, noting his focus on player feedback and the game’s evolution as a 'comfort game,' but does not address the AI controversy directly. The outlets agree on the facts of the AI metadata discovery but differ in emphasis: Kotaku and GoNintendo focus on the AI scandal, while iXBT.games frames it within broader quality control failures.

Why it matters

This incident highlights growing player resistance to undisclosed AI-generated content in video games, particularly in high-profile releases. It underscores the tension between development speed and quality control, as well as the importance of transparency in using AI tools. The backlash may influence industry standards for AI disclosure and the expectations for post-launch support in long-running franchises.

What to watch

Nicalis is expected to provide a statement explaining how the AI-generated music was included and whether it will be replaced with original tracks. McMillen has indicated he is looking into the issue and working to remove the content. The long-term impact on the game’s reputation and the future of AI in indie gaming remains to be seen.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Kotaku