Commerce insiders allege Lutnick’s department stalled chip export enforcement amid internal chaos

3 min read
Source: CBS News
Commerce insiders allege Lutnick’s department stalled chip export enforcement amid internal chaos
Photo: CBS News
TL;DR

Former Commerce Department officials allege that Secretary Howard Lutnick’s tenure was defined by 'chaos' and a failure to enforce AI chip export controls, resulting in a year-long gap in adding firms to the restricted Entity List. While Trump defends Lutnick, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent publicly criticized the department for allowing advanced chips to reach China, highlighting deep internal friction over national security enforcement.

Key points

  • Four anonymous former Commerce officials described the department under Lutnick as 'very chaotic,' with staff often learning of major policy shifts via media reports rather than internal channels.
  • Officials allege that no companies were added to the Entity List for a full year, a first in 18 years, despite evidence of suspicious chip activity in Southeast Asia.
  • Bureau of Industry and Security chief Jeffrey Kessler is accused of micromanaging decisions, blocking enforcement actions, and requiring staff to package options for higher-level decision-makers.
  • The department lost two senior experts, Matthew Borman and Eileen Albanese, shortly after Lutnick took office, triggering an exodus of up to 50 skilled staff members.
  • Key roles in the Bureau of Industry and Security, including principal deputy assistant secretary for export administration, remain vacant.

Background

This scrutiny follows the resignation of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, who admitted an affair with a woman U.S. intelligence agencies suspected was a Chinese spy. Previous reporting indicated that a Commerce investigation into the firm Megaspeed was halted after Nvidia’s general counsel contacted officials. Additionally, Senate Commerce ranking member Maria Cantwell has called for oversight, citing failures to block advanced AI chips from reaching Chinese adversaries.

How outlets are covering it

CBS News highlights internal testimony regarding 'chaos' and a lack of action on chip smuggling, noting that enforcement officers found suspicious activity but directors allegedly took no action. Politico reports that President Trump publicly defended Lutnick, stating he has done a 'very good job' and has no plans to fire him, despite the controversy. The Guardian provides broader context on Trump’s upcoming Asia trip, noting he is under pressure to address the Nvidia scandal with Chinese leaders but has indicated he will not raise the subject. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, cited by CBS News, publicly blamed Lutnick for failing to follow through on chip ban enforcement, creating a visible rift within the administration.

Why it matters

The alleged failure to enforce export controls could allow significant quantities of advanced AI chips to reach China, undermining U.S. national security and technological dominance. The internal dysfunction and loss of experienced staff at the Commerce Department may hinder future enforcement efforts, while the public dispute between Treasury and Commerce signals deep administrative friction over critical economic and security policies.

What to watch

Democrats are expected to take control of Congress in January, where they plan to investigate the administration’s handling of chip exports and corporate dealings. The Commerce Department has recently imposed new license requirements for exporting chips to several Asian countries to close loopholes, though it claims this was directed by the Treasury and National Security Council. Trump is set to travel to Asia for the APEC forum, where he will meet with Chinese and Russian leaders, though he has stated he does not plan to discuss the Nvidia scandal with Xi Jinping.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on CBS News