DOJ Abandons Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Wins Majority

4 min read
Source: The New York Times
DOJ Abandons Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Wins Majority
Photo: The New York Times
TL;DR

The Trump administration has dropped its legal bid to block the certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate election results. The Justice Department asked a federal appeals court to dismiss its lawsuit as moot following Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory. The suit, filed in October, sought to prevent certification until an investigation could determine if voters were confused by the presence of a second candidate named Dan Sullivan. Peltola won with 50.13% of the vote, securing an outright majority that rendered the disputed ballots irrelevant to the outcome.

Key points

  • The Justice Department filed a motion on Thursday to have the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declare its lawsuit moot, citing Peltola’s decisive victory.
  • The lawsuit, initiated at President Trump’s direction, argued that Alaska should not certify the results until it could be determined whether voter confusion caused by a duplicate name affected the outcome.
  • Mary Peltola won the race with 50.13% of the vote, meaning the state did not need to use ranked-choice tabulation to determine a winner, and the votes for the decoy candidate did not impact the final result.
  • Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward stated in the filing that the government 'reluctantly acknowledges' there is no longer a means to examine whether votes cast for the second Sullivan were intended for the incumbent.
  • The Alaska Supreme Court had previously ruled that the second candidate’s inclusion on the ballot was legal, and a federal judge had dismissed the initial suit in November, ruling that segregating ballots would violate voter secrecy.

Background

In late October, the Justice Department filed a lawsuit to block the certification of Alaska’s Senate race, arguing that the presence of a non-incumbent candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan alongside incumbent Dan S. Sullivan could confuse voters. Democratic campaigns and voting rights groups moved to intervene, arguing the executive branch lacked authority to intervene in state-run elections. On November 1, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit, ruling that the government failed to provide a method for segregating ballots without violating voter secrecy. The Justice Department vowed to appeal, but the race proceeded to Election Day.

How outlets are covering it

The New York Times emphasizes that the administration abandoned its legal maneuver two days after the Associated Press called the race for Peltola, noting that Democrats had recruited the second candidate. The Guardian highlights that Peltola, a Yup’ik, will join Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan as the first two Native American women to serve in the U.S. Senate, while also noting that Peltola denied involvement in the recruitment of the decoy candidate. NBC News focuses on the legal mechanics, noting that the administration’s claim that it was acting to protect election integrity was undermined by the fact that Peltola won an outright majority, making the disputed votes irrelevant. All sources agree that the lawsuit was an unprecedented attempt by the executive branch to intervene in state election certification, but they differ in emphasis: The Times and Guardian focus on the political implications and the identity of the winner, while NBC News focuses on the legal failure of the administration’s arguments regarding ballot secrecy and standing.

Why it matters

The dismissal of the lawsuit marks the end of a significant legal challenge to the integrity of the 2026 midterm elections. It confirms that state-level election certification processes, including the handling of contested ballots, remain outside the direct purview of the federal executive branch. The outcome ensures that Mary Peltola will take office, adding to the Democratic gains in the Senate and highlighting the limits of federal intervention in state election disputes. The case also underscores the legal barriers to challenging election results based on alleged voter confusion when the outcome is not affected by the disputed votes.

What to watch

Mary Peltola is expected to take office as a U.S. Senator from Alaska. The Justice Department’s withdrawal from the case concludes the federal legal dispute, though state-level investigations into campaign conduct may continue. The outcome of the Alaska race, along with other close races, will determine the final composition of the U.S. Senate and the balance of power in Congress.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The New York Times