BYU's Historic 28-24 Upset of Notre Dame Defined by Bachmeier's Triple Threat and Controversial End

Key points

• BYU defeated No. 2 Notre Dame 28-24 at LaVell Edwards Stadium, marking the highest-ranked opponent BYU has beaten since 1990.
• Bear Bachmeier threw for 224 yards and scored three touchdowns (rushing, passing, receiving), a historic feat against a top-five team.
• The game ended with a Big 12-acknowledged clock error, where officials stopped the game with one second remaining, though the result was upheld.
• BYU defensive lineman Justin Kirkland admitted yelling 'hut' during a late-half spike attempt, leading to a fumble by CJ Carr that sealed the halftime lead.
• Advanced metrics showed BYU was the superior team, forcing 27% three-and-outs versus Notre Dame's 11%, despite a controversial final-play outcome.

Background

Prior to this matchup, Notre Dame had won 16 consecutive games and was ranked No. 2, while BYU was No. 8. The game was part of a broader pattern of clock controversies in the 2026 season, including similar incidents involving Michigan and Western Michigan. BYU's victory is expected to elevate them to the No. 1 ranking in the AP Top 25.

How outlets are covering it

BYU Athletics emphasized the team's resilience and Bachmeier's historic performance, noting the close nature of the game. USA Today highlighted the specific incident of Kirkland yelling 'hut,' which led to Carr's fumble, and noted Notre Dame coach Marcus Freeman's refusal to blame officials. BYU Cougars On SI focused on advanced metrics, arguing BYU was statistically superior with a 93.9% win expectancy, despite the controversial ending. All sources agree the result stands despite the clock error.

Why it matters

The upset ends Notre Dame's 16-game winning streak and potentially moves BYU to No. 1 in the AP rankings. It highlights the impact of individual performances (Bachmeier) and controversial officiating on high-stakes college football outcomes. The game also showcases the growing competitiveness of BYU on the national stage.

What to watch

BYU will travel to Orlando, Florida, to face the UCF Knights in the Acrisure Bounce House on Saturday. Broadcast details are expected to be announced on Monday. Notre Dame will likely face scrutiny regarding their defensive execution and clock management in future games.