Suspect in Playas del Coco Homicide of American Businessman Captured in San José
Costa Rican authorities arrested a 22-year-old woman, identified as Ortiz, suspected of murdering American businessman Marc Walter Fleming in his Playas del Coco condominium. Fleming was found dead on September 27 with head injuries, and investigators allege Ortiz struck him with a blender container during a confrontation. The arrest concludes a two-week search that began after an initial raid on her home failed to locate her. A second suspect, Roxana Zeledón Abarca, was previously detained for allegedly helping Ortiz flee. Investigators are also pursuing three stolen Rolex watches and bank cards used after the killing.
Key points
- OIJ agents arrested Ortiz in San Felipe de Alajuelita, ending a search that started after she evaded capture during an October 16 raid in Desamparados.
- Marc Walter Fleming, a 74-year-old former California metals executive, was found dead in his Playas del Coco condo on September 27 with multiple head injuries.
- Investigators allege Fleming met Ortiz online or through a referral, and security footage shows her leaving the apartment alone approximately two hours after they entered together.
- Roxana Zeledón Abarca was arrested on October 16 for allegedly transporting Ortiz from Guanacaste to San José; she remains in preventive detention for three months.
- Police are searching for three Rolex watches, each valued at over $25,000, and bank cards allegedly used by the suspects to make purchases in Guanacaste after the homicide.
Background
Our archive notes that Fleming was identified as a 74-year-old American businessman and former senior executive in the metals industry who had recently purchased the condominium. Earlier reports from October 14 and 15 described the suspect as a fair-skinned, slender woman with black hair, approximately 1.60 meters tall, and highlighted the public appeal for assistance in locating her. The October 30 archive entry confirmed the arrest of Ortiz and the ongoing investigation into the stolen property, aligning with the current primary source details.
Why it matters
The resolution of this high-profile case may influence security protocols and expatriate safety advisories in Costa Rica’s popular Guanacaste beach communities. The involvement of stolen high-value assets and bank cards suggests a potential motive beyond a simple domestic dispute, raising concerns about targeted crimes against foreign residents. The successful arrest after a two-week manhunt also demonstrates the effectiveness of combining public intelligence with OIJ investigative resources in complex homicide cases.
What to watch
Ortiz is expected to appear before prosecutors, who will determine whether to request preventive detention. Investigators will continue analyzing financial transactions, security footage, and evidence from the apartment to establish the exact circumstances of the killing. Authorities have not yet announced a final motive, and both suspects remain presumed innocent until proven guilty in court.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Tico Times