NAZA documentary ignites Israel with citizenship revocation threats and death calls

4 min read
Source: The Guardian
NAZA documentary ignites Israel with citizenship revocation threats and death calls
Photo: The Guardian
TL;DR

The Guardian-produced documentary NAZA, which details Israeli military use of AI to target civilians in Gaza, has triggered a violent backlash in Israel. While the film received a record 25-minute standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and right-wing allies are pushing legislation to strip the filmmakers of their citizenship. The 80-minute film, featuring 24 anonymous Israeli military insiders, has sparked death threats and protests, with critics arguing the government is weaponizing the film to suppress dissent ahead of October elections.

Key points

  • NAZA, directed by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, premiered at Venice to a 25-minute standing ovation, the longest in the festival's history.
  • The 80-minute documentary features 24 anonymized Israeli military and intelligence personnel discussing AI-driven targeting systems in Gaza.
  • Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced plans to legislate against 'defamation' of Israeli soldiers, including revoking citizenship of the filmmakers.
  • Right-wing figures and far-right groups have issued death threats against the directors and their families, with graffiti appearing in Ashdod.
  • The film opens in US cinemas on September 30, but international distribution remains limited, preventing most Israelis from viewing it.
  • Critics, including Haaretz columnist Etan Nechin, argue the extreme reaction indicates a democratic malaise and fear of accountability.

Background

NAZA builds on earlier reporting from +972 Magazine and Local Call, which first exposed allegations of AI-based targeting in Gaza. The film, produced by The Guardian, follows the directors' previous work on No Other Land. Prior to its release, Israeli media had largely avoided covering the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, with a 2025 study finding minimal coverage of Palestinian casualties. The documentary's release has intensified existing tensions over press freedom and dissent in Israel, particularly since the October 2023 Hamas attack.

How outlets are covering it

The Guardian and Vox emphasize the film's power to expose mass killing and the extreme, violent reaction from Israeli right-wing figures, including calls for death and citizenship revocation. Al Jazeera highlights that the core allegations are not new but have only now sparked a unified, cross-party backlash in Israel, noting that even opposition figures like Gadi Eisenkot and Naftali Bennett have condemned the film. Al Jazeera also points to a 2025 study showing minimal coverage of Palestinian casualties in Israeli media, suggesting the film's impact stems from a long-standing media blackout. The Guardian notes that the right is exploiting the film's unavailability to Israelis to craft a narrative of treason, while Al Jazeera frames the reaction as a 'lynch mob' mentality driven by election politics. Vox focuses on the global reception versus the domestic fury, noting that few Israelis have seen the film yet it dominates the political debate.

Why it matters

The NAZA controversy reveals the fragility of press freedom and dissent in Israel, with the government using the film to target critics and suppress accountability for the Gaza war. The extreme backlash, including death threats and citizenship revocation threats, signals a shift toward authoritarianism and the weaponization of media to control public narrative. The film's global success contrasts with its domestic suppression, highlighting the gap between international scrutiny and Israeli public discourse. As Israel approaches its October elections, the incident underscores how the right-wing is leveraging fear and nationalism to consolidate power, potentially setting a precedent for punishing journalists and filmmakers for critical reporting.

What to watch

The film is set to open in US cinemas on September 30, with international distribution plans to be announced. Netanyahu is expected to advance legislation to revoke citizenship of those deemed to 'defame' Israeli soldiers. The October elections will likely see the NAZA controversy used as a political weapon by right-wing parties. Human rights organizations and international press freedom groups are expected to continue defending the filmmakers, while the Israeli left and media may face increased pressure to align with the government's narrative. The film's eventual release in Israel could trigger further public debate or suppression, depending on the political climate.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Guardian