Justice Secretary Demands Discipline for Barristers Using Rape Myths After Brand Trial

Justice Secretary Alex Norris has urged the Bar Standards Board to discipline barristers who use rape myths in trials, citing the defense tactics in the Russell Brand case. While the government and victim charities condemn such arguments, the Bar Council warns against mandatory training that could reduce the number of available defense lawyers.
Key points
- Justice Secretary Alex Norris wrote to the Bar Standards Board (BSB) stating that perpetuating rape myths in court is 'unacceptable' and could lead to disciplinary action.
- The call follows the Russell Brand trial, where defense barrister Ian Winter KC argued that accusers were not credible because they did not scream, resist, or attempt to leave.
- Winter KC also questioned the jury on whether Brand could have raped only three of the 'many, many women' he had sex with over a decade.
- The BSB has established an expert group to advise on strengthening standards for barristers in sexual offense cases, though it maintains cases must be decided on evidence, not prejudice.
- Bar Council chair Kirsty Brimow KC warned that mandatory training could be 'problematic' and drive barristers out of the sector, noting a current shortage of lawyers defending rape cases.
- Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley supported calls for judges to direct juries on rape myths in every trial, stating that inaccurate statements should not undermine victim credibility.
Background
This development follows the November 2026 sentencing of Russell Brand, who was convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault and sentenced to 10.5 years in prison. Brand’s defense barrister, Ian Winter KC, previously self-reported to the BSB after a confrontation with a journalist outside the court. The current debate centers on whether regulatory changes are needed to prevent defense attorneys from using victim-blaming tactics, a practice that has drawn criticism from the government, police, and victim advocacy groups.
How outlets are covering it
The BBC and The Guardian report that Justice Secretary Alex Norris is pushing for strict disciplinary measures against barristers who use rape myths, emphasizing that such tactics harm victims and public confidence. The Guardian highlights that Winter KC has self-reported to the BSB. In contrast, the Bar Council, represented by Kirsty Brimow KC, argues that the BSB must remain independent of the government and that mandatory training could exacerbate the shortage of barristers willing to defend rape cases. The Observer provides a critical perspective, arguing that the focus on the trial’s defense tactics often overshadows the systemic issues that allowed Brand’s behavior to persist and the trauma suffered by the victims. While the Ministry of Justice supports stronger protections, the Bar Council emphasizes the defendant’s right to have evidence tested in court.
Why it matters
The push for new rules aims to protect victims from being subjected to victim-blaming arguments during trials, which can discourage reporting and undermine the integrity of the justice system. However, the debate highlights a tension between protecting victims and maintaining the rights of the accused, with concerns that overly strict regulations could reduce the pool of available defense lawyers for serious sexual offense cases.
What to watch
The Bar Standards Board is expected to review the advice from its expert group on strengthening standards for barristers. The government may propose legislative changes requiring judges to direct juries on rape myths in every trial, as suggested by Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley. The Bar Council will likely continue to advocate for voluntary rather than mandatory training to avoid reducing the number of barristers willing to handle sensitive cases.
- Barristers must stop using rape myths in trials, justice secretary says BBC
- Barristers could be barred from practice over use of rape myths, warns justice secretary The Guardian
- Lawyers must stop using ‘rape myths’ in wake of Russell Brand trial The Times
- UK Government Adviser Calls for Scrutiny of How Sexual Assault Victims Are Treated in Court Fashion Times UK
- Why are we still putting rape victims’ credibility on trial? The Observer
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on BBC