Jersey Mike's Turkey Sub Tops Subway and Jimmy John's in Business Insider Taste Test

Key points

• Jersey Mike's turkey and provolone sub cost $9.80 and was praised for its moist turkey, fresh cheese, and signature 'juice' seasoning.
• Subway's $7.99 turkey sandwich featured generous but dry turkey and excessive mayonnaise, with bread described as stale.
• Jimmy John's $7.99 Turkey Tom was noted for its 8-inch length but criticized for lacking cheese, onions, and overall flavor.
• The tester measured each sandwich to verify advertised lengths, finding Subway's 6-inch sub was actually 5.5 inches.
• Jersey Mike's was deemed the best value despite the higher price, while Subway and Jimmy John's were considered acceptable for quick meals.

Background

This comparison follows a long-standing debate among American consumers regarding the quality and value of fast-casual sandwich chains. While Subway has historically marketed customization, recent years have seen competitors like Jersey Mike's and Jimmy John's emphasize fresh preparation and specific recipes. The archive contains unrelated coverage of entertainment and political events, offering no direct background on this food industry comparison.

Why it matters

The results highlight consumer preferences for flavor and substance over convenience or price in the fast-casual sandwich market. Jersey Mike's victory suggests that diners are willing to pay a premium for perceived quality and freshness, while Subway and Jimmy John's face pressure to improve their standard offerings to remain competitive.

What to watch

Subway has responded by emphasizing its customization options, suggesting that customers can tailor sandwiches to their preferences. Jersey Mike's and Jimmy John's did not provide comments. Future comparisons may focus on other menu items or regional variations.