NC Utility Regulator Resigns After Dissenting on Duke Energy Rate Hike

Donald Van der Vaart, a Republican member of the North Carolina Utilities Commission, will resign effective January 1, 2027. His departure follows his dissent against a recent decision allowing Duke Energy to raise residential rates by approximately 9.5% over two years. Van der Vaart argued the ruling unfairly shifts financial risks from data centers to everyday customers.
Key points
- Van der Vaart, appointed by State Treasurer Brad Briner in April 2025, is stepping down four and a half years before his term ends.
- He dissented from the rate increase vote, arguing that data center rules could leave residential customers paying for nearly half of infrastructure costs if tech developers break contracts early.
- The commission approved average annual residential rate increases of 4.7% for Duke Energy Carolinas and 4.8% for Duke Energy Progress, effective January 1, 2027.
- Van der Vaart was barred from voting on Duke’s carbon plan earlier this week after missing over two weeks of evidentiary hearings.
- Briner stated he would appoint a replacement in the coming weeks, noting Van der Vaart’s departure opens a seat just before Democrats take control of the state House.
Background
This resignation occurs amid broader national debates over utility rate hikes and data center infrastructure costs. Recent archives show similar regulatory battles in Michigan and Wisconsin, where regulators trimmed utility requests to protect consumers. A Consumer Reports survey also linked rising power bills to increased household financial stress, highlighting public distrust of utility profit margins and data center demand.
How outlets are covering it
The News & Observer and WRAL emphasize Van der Vaart’s dissent regarding data center cost-shifting and his absence from key votes. Duke Energy frames the approved rates as a 'cost-effective path' that balances affordability with necessary reliability investments, citing new safeguards for large users. Axios notes the rate hike aligns with a prior settlement reducing Duke’s initial 18% request to 9.5%, while environmental groups criticized the approved carbon plan for delaying coal retirements and expanding natural gas generation. Van der Vaart’s background as a former DEQ secretary and EPA advisory board member adds a layer of conservative regulatory history to his departure.
Why it matters
The resignation highlights deep regulatory divisions over how to allocate the financial burden of massive data center infrastructure. As North Carolina faces population growth and energy demand, the departure of a key Republican voice may influence future decisions on utility rates, carbon plans, and the balance between shareholder returns and consumer protection.
What to watch
State Treasurer Brad Briner will announce a replacement for Van der Vaart in the coming weeks. The new commission member will join a body currently split between three Republicans and two Democrats, just as Democrats assume control of the state House. Duke Energy’s new rates and utility merger take effect January 1, 2027, with rates gradually blending over time.
- Republican utility regulator unexpectedly resigns after Duke Energy decision News & Observer
- NC utilities commissioner resigns days after Duke Energy rate hike decisions WRAL
- Duke Energy customers will see higher bills starting in January after rate increases approved WCNC
- North Carolina regulators approve more cost-effective path to strengthen reliability and power the state’s future Duke Energy | News Center
- NC regulators give green light to new Duke Energy electricity rates Axios
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on News & Observer