First Circuit Rejects ICE’s Mandatory Detention, Widening Split Before Supreme Court

3 min read
Source: Politico
TL;DR

The 1st Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the Trump administration’s mandatory detention policy for long-term undocumented residents is an unlawful distortion of a 1996 statute. This decision joins six other circuits rejecting the policy, while only the 5th and 8th Circuits have sided with the government. The ruling challenges a July 2025 DHS directive that reclassified longtime residents as 'seeking admission,' a move that drove ICE detention levels to a record 73,000 by January 2026. With over 460 judges nationwide rejecting the policy, the issue is now poised for Supreme Court resolution.

Key points

  • The 1st Circuit ruled that the 1996 statute applies only to recent border-crossers, not long-term residents, rejecting the administration’s 'seeking admission' interpretation.
  • The policy, adopted in July 2025, led to a record 73,000 detainees by January 2026, according to the court.
  • Six circuits have rejected the policy, while the 5th and 8th Circuits have sided with the government, creating a split that is likely to reach the Supreme Court.
  • In Minnesota, over 50% of detainees were released or granted bond hearings despite the 8th Circuit’s ruling, as attorneys shifted to constitutional and procedural challenges.
  • The Board of Immigration Appeals had backed the policy in October 2025, but the 1st Circuit called the interpretation a 'grossly mistaken' reading of the law.

Background

This ruling follows a series of appeals court decisions in 2026, including the 4th Circuit’s rejection of the policy in July and the 2nd Circuit’s reinstatement of detention in a separate case. The policy was first adopted in July 2025, leading to a surge in habeas petitions and court backlogs. ICE detention levels had already reached a record 73,000 by January 2026, according to the 1st Circuit’s opinion.

How outlets are covering it

Politico and Raw Story emphasize the 1st Circuit’s rejection of the policy as a distortion of decades-old practice, with Judge Montecalvo calling the administration’s interpretation 'beyond recognition.' Fox 9 highlights the practical impact in Minnesota, where over 50% of detainees were released despite the 8th Circuit’s ruling, as attorneys shifted to constitutional challenges. The Trump administration, via DOJ and DHS, continues to defend the policy as lawful, calling judicial rulings 'activist' and 'legally erroneous.'

Why it matters

The ruling underscores a deepening split in the federal judiciary over the scope of mandatory detention, with the Supreme Court likely to resolve the conflict. The policy’s impact on long-term residents and the record detention levels raise significant due-process and constitutional concerns, while the administration’s stance risks further legal challenges and court backlogs.

What to watch

The Supreme Court is expected to take up the case this fall to resolve the circuit split. The administration may continue to appeal lower court rulings, while attorneys may shift to constitutional and procedural challenges. The policy’s impact on detention levels and court backlogs will likely remain a focal point in immigration enforcement debates.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Politico