First Circuit Rejects ICE’s Mandatory Detention, Widening Split Before Supreme Court
The 1st Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that the Trump administration’s mandatory detention policy for long-term undocumented residents is an unlawful distortion of a 1996 statute. This decision joins six other circuits rejecting the policy, while only the 5th and 8th Circuits have sided with the government. The ruling challenges a July 2025 DHS directive that reclassified longtime residents as 'seeking admission,' a move that drove ICE detention levels to a record 73,000 by January 2026. With over 460 judges nationwide rejecting the policy, the issue is now poised for Supreme Court resolution.