DOJ Drops Alaska Election Suit as Peltola Wins Majority, but Criminal Probe Shifts to Campaign

3 min read
Source: The Daily Beast
DOJ Drops Alaska Election Suit as Peltola Wins Majority, but Criminal Probe Shifts to Campaign
Photo: The Daily Beast
TL;DR

The Trump administration has withdrawn its lawsuit challenging the certification of the Alaska U.S. Senate race, declaring the case moot after Democrat Mary Peltola secured an outright majority. While the civil suit is dropped, a separate criminal investigation into alleged voter fraud involving a look-alike candidate has shifted its focus from the third-party candidate to Peltola’s campaign and Democratic operatives.

Key points

  • The Justice Department asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to dismiss its October lawsuit, stating it could no longer determine voter intent due to ballot secrecy.
  • Peltola won with 50.13% of the vote, defeating incumbent Republican Dan S. Sullivan by a margin that renders the disputed ballots irrelevant to the outcome.
  • The DOJ has shifted its criminal investigation away from third-party candidate Daniel J. Sullivan and toward Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
  • Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy refused to confirm Peltola will take office in January, citing ongoing state and federal probes, though he acknowledged the vote gap is problematic.
  • Peltola’s victory gives Democrats a 56-seat Senate majority, their largest since 2011, and marks the ninth Republican seat flipped in the 2026 midterms.

Background

The dispute began in October when the DOJ, at President Trump’s urging, filed a lawsuit to block certification of the Alaska race. Trump alleged that the presence of Daniel J. Sullivan, a candidate with a name similar to incumbent Dan S. Sullivan, was a tactic to defraud voters. A federal judge had previously rejected the initial bid to delay certification, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled the third candidate’s ballot placement legal. This withdrawal follows a similar DOJ retreat in a California ballot counting dispute earlier this month.

How outlets are covering it

The Daily Beast and CNN report that the DOJ has officially abandoned its civil lawsuit, with Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward acknowledging the case is moot. However, CNN notes a significant shift in the criminal probe, which now targets Peltola’s campaign and Democratic consultants for allegedly recruiting a 'spoiler' candidate, a move Democrats deny. Democracy Docket highlights a conflicting stance from Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy, who, despite the DOJ’s withdrawal, continues to support a potential challenge by Sen. Sullivan and refuses to confirm Peltola’s seating. Yahoo provides the broader context, noting that Peltola’s win secures a historic 56-seat Democratic majority in the Senate, a development the DOJ’s legal maneuvering failed to prevent.

Why it matters

The withdrawal of the lawsuit ensures Peltola can be certified and seated, solidifying a Democratic majority in the Senate that will likely challenge President Trump’s agenda and launch investigations into his administration. However, the shift in the DOJ’s criminal probe toward Peltola and Democratic operatives introduces a new layer of legal risk for the incoming senator and signals continued federal scrutiny of election strategies in red states.

What to watch

Alaska officials are expected to certify Peltola’s win by November 25. Sen. Dan S. Sullivan has until December 5 to formally contest the result. The DOJ’s criminal investigation into the Peltola campaign and DSCC will continue, potentially leading to charges if prosecutors find evidence of wrongdoing, while Democrats prepare to leverage their new Senate majority for legislative and oversight actions.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Daily Beast