Trump Administration Appeals to Supreme Court to Block Counting of 20,000 California Mail Ballots
The Trump administration has filed an emergency appeal with the Supreme Court, seeking to set aside approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots in California ahead of the November 3 midterm elections. The federal government argues these ballots belong to non-citizens and must be excluded until citizenship is verified. However, lower courts have rejected this request, with a district judge warning that segregating the ballots would disenfranchise citizens and disrupt the election. California officials state that removing the ballots now is logistically impossible as they have already been processed and commingled with valid votes. The Justice Department claims that once mixed, the challenged ballots cannot be separated, while state leaders condemn the move as a desperate attempt to undermine the democratic process.
Key points
- The Justice Department requested a 'limited injunction' from the Supreme Court to pause the counting of 20,000 disputed ballots in California.
- Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that California cannot separate the challenged ballots from valid ones once they are commingled.
- A district court judge previously denied the request, warning it could disenfranchise citizens and erode trust in the democratic process.
- A 2-1 appeals court panel upheld the district judge's order, with one dissenting judge arguing California's refusal to separate ballots violates federal law.
- California Attorney General Rob Bonta described the appeal as an attempt to trample the rule of law and undermine elections.
- Voting in California began in early October, with hundreds of thousands of ballots already processed, making late-stage segregation logistically unfeasible for state officials.
Background
This dispute follows a September 2026 Supreme Court ruling that blocked a Trump-era system for vetting mail ballots using citizenship lists, leading the USPS to halt development of such verification tools. The current legal battle is part of a broader conflict over election procedures in key states, occurring just days before voters decide control of Congress. The administration has previously sought to restrict mail ballots but faced rejections from the Supreme Court in earlier attempts.
Why it matters
The outcome could determine whether thousands of votes are counted in a pivotal midterm election, potentially influencing the balance of power in Congress. It also tests the limits of federal intervention in state election administration and the feasibility of verifying voter citizenship in real-time during an active election cycle.
What to watch
The Supreme Court must decide whether to grant the emergency injunction requested by the Justice Department. If denied, California will proceed with counting the ballots as scheduled. If granted, the state may be forced to attempt to segregate the disputed votes, a task officials have described as logistically impossible.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on AP News