Baja California court imposes 158-year sentences in 2024 surfer murders
A judge in Ensenada, Mexico, sentenced three men to 158 years and nine months in prison each for the 2024 murders of Australian brothers Callum and Jake Robinson and American Carter Rhoad. The victims were killed during a botched robbery on a secluded beach in Baja California. The ruling concludes a lengthy legal process that began with the discovery of the bodies in May 2024. While prosecutors sought a higher penalty, the court imposed the maximum allowable term for the specific charges of homicide, violent robbery, and vehicle theft. The case has significantly impacted tourism in the region, with local officials noting a sharp decline in visitor numbers since the incident.
Key points
- Sentencing: Three men were sentenced to 158 years and nine months in prison each on October 16, 2026, in Ensenada, Baja California.
- Victims: The victims were Australian brothers Callum (33) and Jake (30) Robinson, and American Carter Rhoad (30), who were killed in April 2024.
- Crime details: Prosecutors alleged the attackers shot the victims to steal tires from their vehicle after the victims resisted the robbery.
- Legal outcome: The sentence represents the maximum allowable term for the charges, despite prosecutors seeking 210 years per defendant.
- Economic impact: Local surfers and officials reported a major drop in tourism to the region following the high-profile killings.
Background
The case gained international attention in 2024 when the bodies of the three surfers were found in a well in Baja California. The victims had traveled from San Diego to Punta San José for a surfing trip. In November 2025, an accomplice, Ary Gisell Silva Raya, was sentenced to 20 years in a separate abbreviated trial. The guilty verdict for the three main defendants was issued in early October 2026, following a month-long trial.
How outlets are covering it
All outlets report the 158-year sentence, though The New York Times notes the men were also ordered to pay approximately $85,000 plus funeral expenses to the victims' families. The New York Post and Fox News emphasize the impact on tourism, citing the Baja California surfers' association. The BBC highlights the shock in Australia and the local community, noting the area was previously considered safe from the violence seen in other parts of Mexico. The New York Times provides the most detailed legal context, including the financial restitution order.
Why it matters
The sentencing concludes a high-profile case that exposed safety risks for tourists in Mexico's tourism-dependent regions. The significant drop in visitor numbers highlights the economic consequences of violent crime in areas reliant on international tourism. The case also underscores the legal limits on sentencing in Mexican courts, where the maximum term for these charges is lower than what prosecutors sought.
What to watch
The three convicted men will serve their sentences in Mexican prisons. The financial restitution order will be enforced. The case may continue to influence tourism policies and safety advisories for travelers in Baja California.
- 3 men sentenced to more than 158 years for killing Australian brothers, US surf pal in Mexico New York Post
- Three men get 158 years each for murdering American and Australian surfers, dumping bodies in Mexican well Fox News
- Three men jailed for 158 years each for murdering Australian and US surfers in Mexico BBC
- Mexican Judge Sentences 3 Men to 159 Years Each in Surfer Killings The New York Times
- 3 men sentenced to more than 158 years for the killings of Australian, US surfers in Mexico ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on New York Post