Conflicting Glyphosate Studies Clash as EPA Deadline Nears

3 min read
Source: Politico
TL;DR

A new, non-peer-reviewed paper requested by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. argues that existing research links glyphosate to cancer, aiming to pressure the EPA before its Monday review deadline. Simultaneously, a peer-reviewed study from the University of Nebraska found no statistical link between county-level glyphosate use and non-Hodgkin lymphoma rates. The EPA is currently updating its risk assessment, with final conclusions expected next year.

Key points

  • HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and former adviser Calley Means released a paper on a public repository Friday, summarizing research linking glyphosate to cancer.
  • The paper has not undergone peer review or publication in a scientific journal.
  • Means stated the timing was designed to force the EPA to regulate the chemical more stringently, noting that Monday is the deadline for considering new scientific studies.
  • A separate study published Nov. 11 in Frontiers in Public Health found no statistically significant association between glyphosate application and non-Hodgkin lymphoma incidence across 93 Nebraska counties.
  • The EPA and HHS announced a plan in September to expand the volume of information for an updated glyphosate risk assessment, expected to be completed next year.

Background

Glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, remains a controversial herbicide. Previous coverage has highlighted ongoing debates regarding its safety, with some studies suggesting links to cancer while others, including a 2018 Agricultural Health Study, found no such association. The current dispute occurs against a backdrop of broader regulatory reviews and public health initiatives under the Make America Healthy Again movement.

How outlets are covering it

Politico emphasizes the political maneuvering behind the new paper, highlighting that it was requested by Kennedy and Means to pressure the EPA. The Western Producer and DTN Progressive Farmer focus on the scientific findings of the Nebraska study, noting that while some eastern counties showed higher cancer rates alongside glyphosate use, the overall data did not support a causal link. Both agricultural outlets highlight that the Nebraska study did not measure individual exposure, limiting its conclusions, whereas Politico notes the new paper has not been peer-reviewed. The sources disagree on the current state of evidence: one side argues existing research backs regulation, while the other points to recent data showing no overall statistical link.

Why it matters

The outcome of the EPA’s review could significantly impact agricultural practices and public health policies. The conflicting studies highlight the ongoing scientific debate and the potential for regulatory changes based on political pressure versus peer-reviewed data. The deadline for considering new studies adds urgency to the EPA’s decision-making process.

What to watch

The EPA is expected to complete its updated risk assessment next year. The agency will systematically evaluate peer-reviewed research published since its previous assessment, including evidence on cancer, genotoxicity, reproductive, and developmental effects. The outcome will determine whether glyphosate faces stricter regulations or remains approved for use.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Politico