Vegetarians Lag Behind Meat Eaters in Muscle Mass Gains Despite Equal Strength Improvements
A 12-week trial of adults over 55 found that while vegetarians and meat eaters achieved similar strength gains through resistance training, meat eaters gained significantly more muscle mass. The study suggests that meeting high protein targets is crucial for vegetarians to maximize muscle growth in older age.
Key points
- A randomized trial involving 108 adults aged 55 and older compared vegetarian and omnivorous diets over 12 weeks.
- Both groups engaged in resistance training three times a week and were counseled to consume at least 1.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight daily.
- Strength and physical performance improved similarly for both groups, with no significant difference in outcomes like leg press or chair stand tests.
- Omnivores gained approximately 70 percent more muscle mass in arms and legs (+0.66 kg) compared to vegetarians (+0.38 kg).
- Vegetarians who consumed more protein showed greater muscle gains, while omnivores reached a saturation point where extra protein yielded no further benefit.
- The study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, notes that the cohort was predominantly White, healthy, and highly educated, limiting generalizability.
Background
Recent research, including a 2026 trial on creatine, has highlighted the importance of protein and supplements for muscle maintenance in adults over 45. While previous studies suggest vegetarian diets can support long-term health and longevity, this new trial adds nuance by showing that plant-based diets may require stricter adherence to protein targets to prevent muscle loss in older adults. This follows earlier findings that underweight vegetarians may have lower longevity, emphasizing the critical role of adequate protein intake for aging populations.
Why it matters
As the population ages, maintaining muscle mass is vital for physical function and independence. This study provides evidence that while vegetarian diets are viable for strength, they may require more careful protein management than omnivorous diets to achieve equivalent muscle growth. For older adults, particularly those with low appetite, ensuring sufficient high-quality protein is essential to prevent sarcopenia and maintain functional health.
What to watch
Researchers will likely investigate the specific mechanisms behind the protein quality differences between animal and plant sources. Future studies may explore whether specific plant-based protein combinations or supplements can close the muscle mass gap observed in this trial. Additionally, broader trials with more diverse populations are needed to determine if these findings apply to older adults with different health backgrounds or dietary restrictions.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on ScienceAlert