NC State Health Plan to Drop Atrium Health After Court Denies Injunction

4 min read
Source: WRAL
NC State Health Plan to Drop Atrium Health After Court Denies Injunction
Photo: WRAL
TL;DR

North Carolina Treasurer Brad Briner announced that the State Health Plan will remove Atrium Health from its network starting next year. This decision follows a month-long dispute over pricing and a recent court ruling that denied the state’s request to block Atrium’s new affordability program. The plan covers 750,000 state employees and faces a potential deficit, while Atrium is simultaneously pursuing a merger with WakeMed.

Key points

  • Treasurer Brad Briner stated that Atrium Health will be taken out of the State Health Plan network for 2027 due to ongoing pricing disputes.
  • The State Health Plan covers over 750,000 state employees, retirees, and family members, and faces a projected deficit of hundreds of millions of dollars.
  • Atrium Health launched an 'Affordability Protection Program' to lower out-of-pocket costs for plan members, which the state argues illegally interferes with the plan’s structure.
  • Judge Matthew Houston denied the state’s request for a temporary restraining order, allowing Atrium’s program to proceed despite the state’s claims of financial harm.
  • The State Health Plan may raise premiums for all members by up to $50 per month in 2028 to maintain solvency, potentially doubling 2027 premiums.
  • Atrium Health is currently in the process of merging with Raleigh-based WakeMed, a deal that faces state and federal review and has drawn criticism from the state treasurer.

Background

The State Health Plan has faced growing financial pressures, with previous attempts to cap hospital payments failing under former Treasurer Dale Folwell. The plan recently implemented a tiered provider system to manage costs, designating UNC Health and Novant Health as preferred providers. Atrium Health, the largest healthcare chain in North Carolina, has been in conflict with the state over pricing and network inclusion. The current dispute is part of a broader trend of healthcare cost management challenges in North Carolina, with the plan projecting a deficit of $507 million in 2026 and between $800 million and $900 million in 2027.

How outlets are covering it

WRAL.com emphasizes the state’s decision to remove Atrium from the network as a direct response to the court’s denial of the injunction, highlighting the financial strain on the plan. The Raleigh News & Observer focuses on the legal battle, noting that the judge found the state had not demonstrated irreparable harm, while also detailing the potential premium increases for all members. Carolina Journal highlights the state’s argument that Atrium’s program is a 'shell game' that shifts costs back to the plan, while Atrium’s spokesperson defends the program as a necessary measure to protect members from higher costs. Fierce Healthcare notes that the state accused Atrium of acting in bad faith by launching the program just before open enrollment, while Atrium maintains its offer to match preferred provider discounts is still on the table. All sources agree on the core facts of the dispute and the court’s ruling, but differ in their emphasis on the financial implications and the legality of Atrium’s actions.

Why it matters

This dispute has significant implications for the 750,000 state employees and their families covered by the State Health Plan, as it could lead to higher premiums and reduced access to preferred providers. The outcome of the legal battle and the potential merger between Atrium and WakeMed could reshape the healthcare landscape in North Carolina, affecting costs and access for public servants. The case also highlights the broader challenges of managing healthcare costs in a system where providers and insurers are in conflict over pricing and network inclusion.

What to watch

The State Health Plan will continue to explore legal options to challenge Atrium’s affordability program, while also considering premium increases to maintain solvency. Atrium Health will proceed with its Affordability Protection Program and its merger with WakeMed, which faces state and federal review. The open enrollment period for the State Health Plan has been extended through November 6, 2026, to give members more time to review their options. The outcome of the legal battle and the merger will likely have long-term effects on the financial stability of the State Health Plan and the healthcare market in North Carolina.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on WRAL