French Senate approves 'rioters pay' law amid fears of protest crackdown
The French Senate passed a bill requiring protesters to pay up to 10,000 euros for damage caused during demonstrations, following violent unrest in October. The law, which allows seizure of welfare benefits, faces criticism for potentially chilling the right to protest, while supporters argue it is necessary to hold vandals accountable.
Key points
- The Senate approved the bill by 229 votes to 105, sending it to the National Assembly for further debate.
- The legislation mandates financial liability for individuals who knowingly participate in groups intending vandalism or continue protesting after two police dispersal warnings.
- Critics warn that seizing welfare and housing assistance to cover damages will disproportionately harm vulnerable families.
- Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez emphasized the urgency of the law in response to the violence seen on October 17.
- Far-right leader Marine Le Pen supports the measure, framing it as a restoration of rule of law.
Background
This legislative move follows months of escalating social tension in France. Earlier in October, student protests over school conditions and teacher shortages escalated into nationwide unrest, resulting in clashes with police and hundreds of arrests. The current bill builds on earlier drafts introduced after riots following the UEFA Champions League final in May, but its urgency has increased due to the severe looting and vandalism that occurred during recent demonstrations against rising living costs.
How outlets are covering it
Supporters, including the right-wing and centrist alliance in the Senate and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez, argue the law is essential to ensure that the majority of citizens do not bear the cost of a minority of vandals. They assert that the bill targets specific acts of insurrection and does not criminalize peaceful protesters. Conversely, left-wing parties, trade unions, and human rights organizations like Amnesty International condemn the measure as an authoritarian drift that threatens the fundamental right to protest. Critics, including Communist senator Fabien Gay and Green senator Melanie Vogel, argue that joint liability and the seizure of social benefits constitute collective punishment that will push marginalized families into poverty. The Guardian notes that the law may effectively end street demonstrations due to the financial risk involved, while Euronews highlights that this follows a broader European trend of tougher security measures, such as recent penalties for violent protests in Italy.
Why it matters
The passage of this bill marks a significant shift in French civil liberties, potentially redefining the legal boundaries of public dissent. If enacted, it could set a precedent for holding individuals financially responsible for the actions of others in a crowd, raising concerns about arbitrary enforcement and the erosion of democratic freedoms. The outcome in the National Assembly will determine whether these restrictions become permanent law, influencing how future social movements are organized and policed in France.
What to watch
The bill must now be debated and voted on by the National Assembly, which is politically divided. The government has also proposed additional measures, including bans on the most violent individuals and rapid removal of social media content calling for insurrection. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu is set to meet with student representatives to address their demands for school funding, aiming to de-escalate the ongoing crisis.
- French Senate backs 'make rioters pay' bill despite rights concerns France 24
- French Senate approves bill to hold protesters liable for damage Euronews.com
- Macron accused of putting France’s right to protest at risk with ‘vandal’s law’ The Guardian
- Critics attack 'anti-democratic' French bill making rioters pay Reuters
- French Senate Approves Bill on Collective Responsibility for Protests News.by
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on France 24