Tag

Speech Or Debate Clause

All articles tagged with #speech or debate clause

Judge Boasberg orders partial unsealing of Ilhan Omar search records, excluding key affidavit
politics25 minutes ago

Judge Boasberg orders partial unsealing of Ilhan Omar search records, excluding key affidavit

Chief Judge James Boasberg ordered the release of redacted documents related to the October search of Rep. Ilhan Omar’s Washington home, excluding the main 67-page affidavit. The Justice Department must submit proposed redactions by Friday, with public disclosure expected by Monday. Omar, who has not been charged, denies wrongdoing in the probe into her family’s immigration history.

Judge Boasberg orders partial unsealing of Omar search warrant records, citing speech protections
politics8 hours ago

Judge Boasberg orders partial unsealing of Omar search warrant records, citing speech protections

Chief Judge James Boasberg ruled Tuesday that while the 67-page affidavit supporting the search of Rep. Ilhan Omar’s home remains sealed, legal filings regarding her Speech or Debate Clause protections must be unsealed. The judge gave the Justice Department until Friday to submit redactions for other documents, criticizing the government’s attempt to keep legal arguments confidential despite public comments from administration officials. No charges have been filed against Omar, who denies wrongdoing in the probe into her family’s immigration paperwork.

Omar Confirms Name as DOJ Seizes Devices in Citizenship Probe
politics25 days ago

Omar Confirms Name as DOJ Seizes Devices in Citizenship Probe

Rep. Ilhan Omar confirmed her name is Ilhan Abdullahi Omar, disputing federal filings that list her as Ilhan Nur Said Elmi. Following a federal raid on her Washington home on Oct. 12, she detailed the seizure of 17 items, including phones and notebooks, while denying agents collected her DNA. The Justice Department seeks to strip her citizenship, a move critics call political intimidation, while House leadership has not yet intervened to protect her legislative privileges.

Judge curtails DOJ access to Rep. Omar's records in citizenship fraud probe
politics1 month ago

Judge curtails DOJ access to Rep. Omar's records in citizenship fraud probe

Federal prosecutors faced legal hurdles when a judge restricted their access to Rep. Ilhan Omar's home records during a search tied to an immigration fraud investigation. The probe, which questions the accuracy of citizenship paperwork filed in 2000, intensified just weeks before midterm elections, prompting accusations of political weaponization by the administration.

Blackburn sues Smith over secret phone records, challenging his legal authority
politics1 month ago

Blackburn sues Smith over secret phone records, challenging his legal authority

Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee against former special counsel Jack Smith and the Justice Department. The suit alleges Smith illegally obtained her phone toll records during the 'Arctic Frost' investigation into Trump's 2020 election claims. Filed one day after Smith's Senate testimony, the complaint seeks to declare his appointment unconstitutional and demands the destruction of her data, seeking only $1 in nominal damages to establish accountability.

legal1 month ago

2nd Circuit Judges Question Menendez Conviction’s Legal Basis

A panel of three judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit appeared skeptical of former Senator Bob Menendez’s criminal convictions during oral arguments on September 24, 2026. Menendez’s attorney, former Solicitor General Noel Francisco, argued that Menendez’s actions regarding a U.S. attorney appointment were protected legislative activity under the Constitution’s speech or debate clause. The court questioned the government’s reliance on historical precedents and challenged the definition of 'official acts' under Supreme Court standards. Menendez is currently serving an 11-year sentence for bribery and other charges.

Smith-Jordan feud widens over alleged congressional deception
politics3 months ago

Smith-Jordan feud widens over alleged congressional deception

Jim Jordan urged a DOJ criminal referral against Jack Smith for allegedly lying to Congress about text-message content; Smith’s lawyers call the move dangerous and unprecedented, insisting his Dec. 17 testimony was truthful and that his team was seeking only metadata (dates/times), not message content, highlighting a heightened partisan clash over the DOJ’s handling of Trump-related investigations.

politics4 months ago

Immunity vs. Accountability: 3rd Circuit Deliberates McIver Case

A 3rd Circuit panel wrestles with whether Rep. LaMonica McIver’s alleged assault of federal officers can be shielded by the Constitution’s speech-or-debate immunity and whether the Trump-era DOJ is pursuing the case as selective prosecution, signaling the tension between congressional immunity and accountability as a trial looms over the Newark incident outside Delaney Hall.

politics10 months ago

New Jersey Rep. McIver to Appeal Charges, Citing Congressional Immunity

New Jersey Rep. LaMonica McIver plans to appeal a three‑count indictment over an incident outside a May ICE detention facility, arguing the Constitution’s speech or debate clause shields lawmakers from prosecution for acts tied to their official duties. The appeal to the 3rd Circuit could redefine the scope of congressional immunity after a judge previously declined to dismiss two counts, with prosecutors contesting the immunity argument.

Sen. Kelly Sues Pentagon Over Retaliation for Political Speech
politics10 months ago

Sen. Kelly Sues Pentagon Over Retaliation for Political Speech

Sen. Mark Kelly filed a federal lawsuit against the Pentagon and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, alleging punitive actions tied to his participation in a Democratic video to U.S. troops violated the Constitution, including the Speech or Debate Clause and due‑process protections; the suit also names the Navy Department. The Pentagon has not commented on ongoing litigation, and Hegseth had announced a plan to cut Kelly’s retired pay amid the dispute.

Sen. Kelly Sues Pentagon Chief Over Downgrade of Retired Rank Tied to Anti-Orders Video
politics10 months ago

Sen. Kelly Sues Pentagon Chief Over Downgrade of Retired Rank Tied to Anti-Orders Video

Arizona Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly filed a civil lawsuit against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to block the Pentagon's move to downgrade his retirement rank and pay, arguing the punishment is unconstitutional retaliation for his criticisms of the administration and protected speech, including a video urging service members to refuse illegal orders.

"Judge Orders Trump Ally Scott Perry to Hand Over Phone Records in Election Subversion Probe"
politics2 years ago

"Judge Orders Trump Ally Scott Perry to Hand Over Phone Records in Election Subversion Probe"

A federal judge has ordered Republican Congressman Scott Perry to turn over nearly 1,700 records from his phone to special counsel prosecutors, potentially revealing his involvement in Donald Trump's attempts to overturn the 2020 election results. The judge's ruling allows prosecutors to access the majority of the records, which include discussions about influencing executive branch officials and state officials, as well as communications about the January 6 Capitol attack. The extent to which Perry's communications are protected by the speech or debate clause, which shields members of Congress from legal peril related to their official duties, is still being determined.

Judge orders Rep. Scott Perry to hand over phone records in Jan. 6 and election probe
politics2 years ago

Judge orders Rep. Scott Perry to hand over phone records in Jan. 6 and election probe

A federal judge has ordered Rep. Scott Perry, a Republican from Pennsylvania, to turn over nearly 1,700 cellphone records to government investigators in relation to the Jan. 6 Capitol attack. The judge ruled that the records were not protected by the speech or debate clause of the Constitution. While some records were deemed protected, the remaining ones, including messages about alleged election fraud and the role of the vice president in certifying the electoral vote count, must be disclosed. Perry had previously argued that the clause protected him from the government searching his communications, but the court largely rejected that argument.

"Mike Pence ordered to testify in January 6 investigation"
politics3 years ago

"Mike Pence ordered to testify in January 6 investigation"

A federal judge's secret order requiring Mike Pence to testify about aspects of Donald Trump's bid to subvert the 2020 election was also an unprecedented ruling about the vice presidency itself. It is the first time in U.S. history that a federal judge has concluded that vice presidents are entitled to a form of immunity from prying investigators. Unlike presidents, who draw all their power from the executive branch, vice presidents get their immunity from Congress, Chief U.S. District Court Judge James Boasberg ruled.

Judge orders Pence to testify about Trump conversations in Jan. 6 probe.
politics3 years ago

Judge orders Pence to testify about Trump conversations in Jan. 6 probe.

A federal judge in Washington has ruled that former Vice President Mike Pence must testify before a grand jury about former President Donald Trump's effort to reverse the outcome of the 2020 presidential election. The judge rejected Trump's claims of executive privilege and found they did not apply to any potential testimony by Pence. However, the speech or debate clause in part protects Pence from providing testimony, specifically on congressional matters related to the events of Jan. 6, 2021, though he must testify about any illegal acts by Trump.