Tag

Surrogacy Dispute

All articles tagged with #surrogacy dispute

Texas court leaves custody of critically ill surrogate-born infant undecided as parents and carrier clash over medical authority
legal-and-health1 month ago

Texas court leaves custody of critically ill surrogate-born infant undecided as parents and carrier clash over medical authority

A Los Angeles couple and their surrogate, McKenna West, faced off in a Dallas court on August 26, 2026, over custody of a newborn with a severe heart defect. The judge did not issue a final ruling on conservatorship, leaving a restraining order in place that bars West from seeing the child. The dispute centers on whether the biological parents, Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, will provide life-saving surgeries after previously requesting an abortion. West, an Alaska nurse, seeks sole medical decision-making authority, while the couple asserts parental rights despite the prior termination request.

Texas judge delays ruling in custody battle over newborn with heart defect
legal-and-health1 month ago

Texas judge delays ruling in custody battle over newborn with heart defect

A Dallas judge has extended a temporary restraining order for 14 days, delaying a final decision on custody of a newborn with a severe heart defect. The case involves a California couple, Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, and their surrogate, McKenna West, who moved to Texas to give birth after refusing their request to terminate the pregnancy. The infant, named Rumi by the parents and Gabriel by West, is in critical condition following surgery. West seeks sole medical conservatorship, while the couple asserts parental rights and alleges West breached their surrogacy contract.

Newborn's condition worsens after heart surgery as Texas court delays custody ruling
legal-and-health1 month ago

Newborn's condition worsens after heart surgery as Texas court delays custody ruling

A Dallas judge extended a restraining order preventing surrogate McKenna West from seeing or making medical decisions for her newborn, who is in critical condition after complications from a heart surgery. The biological parents, Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, testified they are committed to the child's care, while West maintains she cannot trust them to provide life-saving treatment. The case, which began with a dispute over a requested abortion, remains unresolved as the court delays a final custody decision.

Surrogate McKenna West Denies 'Political Theater' Accusations as Baby Rumi Recovers from Heart Surgery
legal-and-health2 months ago

Surrogate McKenna West Denies 'Political Theater' Accusations as Baby Rumi Recovers from Heart Surgery

McKenna West, an Alaskan cardiac nurse, published an opinion piece in the New York Post on Thursday to deny accusations that her refusal to abort a fetus with a rare heart defect was 'political theater.' West, who gave birth to the baby in Texas in August, stated her motivation was to give the child, named Rumi by the biological parents and Gabriel by West, a chance at life. The infant underwent a Norwood procedure, the first of three required surgeries for hypoplastic left heart syndrome, on Monday. While West is represented by Alliance Defending Freedom and supported by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, the biological parents, Omar Ahmed and Nausheen Gilkar, maintain they are focused on the child's recovery and deny withholding care. The case remains a multi-state legal battle involving Alaska, California, and Texas, with West seeking custody and the parents seeking damages for breach of contract.