House House Discloses Minimal AI Use in Big Walk Amid IGF Juror Backlash

3 min read
Source: Eurogamer.net
House House Discloses Minimal AI Use in Big Walk Amid IGF Juror Backlash
Photo: Eurogamer.net
TL;DR

Australian studio House House confirmed it used large language models 'sparingly' to debug code in its hit game Big Walk, following a public stance by Independent Games Festival jurors against AI-assisted development. The studio estimates less than 0.1% of the code involved AI, citing a specific technical fix for shadow rendering. While House House apologized for the lack of an internal AI policy, the disclosure has intensified debate within the indie community over the boundaries of acceptable AI use in game development.

Key points

  • House House stated that LLMs were used only in the final stretch of Big Walk's development to resolve difficult technical bugs, specifically regarding shadow caster culling in Unity URP.
  • The studio estimates that well under 0.1% of Big Walk's code was influenced by AI responses, with no other generative AI usage in the game's creation.
  • Nineteen Independent Games Festival jurors issued a statement refusing to vote for any game using generative AI in any capacity, citing a significant increase in such submissions.
  • House House disclosed the AI usage in its IGF submission but not on Steam, as the platform does not require such disclosures, leading to public scrutiny after the jurors' statement.
  • The studio acknowledged the absence of an internal AI policy as a failure and committed to implementing a comprehensive policy for future projects.

Background

This controversy follows a broader trend of AI integration in gaming, such as Embark Studios' recent justification of AI voice acting in Arc Raiders, which faced player backlash. The current dispute highlights growing tensions in the industry regarding the normalization of generative AI tools, particularly in indie spaces that emphasize human craftsmanship.

How outlets are covering it

Eurogamer and GamesIndustry.biz focused on the technical specifics of House House's disclosure, emphasizing the minimal scale of AI usage (under 0.1% of code) and the studio's apology. The Verge highlighted the community's disarray, noting that while some viewed the AI use as a minor technical exception, others saw it as a breach of indie values. Sam Barlow, an IGF juror, clarified that Big Walk was not the primary impetus for the jurors' stance but became a focal point for debating the 'tricky edge case' of minimal AI use. House House itself expressed concern that voluntary disclosures might normalize AI, stating they do not endorse its use and support efforts to limit its harm.

Why it matters

The incident underscores the evolving standards and ethical boundaries in the indie gaming community regarding AI tools. It may influence future policies at major awards like the IGF and could set precedents for how studios disclose AI usage, potentially affecting consumer trust and industry norms.

What to watch

House House plans to implement a comprehensive AI usage policy for future developments. The IGF may consider adopting stricter anti-AI policies for future years, as urged by the dissenting jurors. The broader industry will likely continue to debate the acceptability of AI in game development, with potential impacts on awards, funding, and consumer perception.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Eurogamer.net