McDonald's Outperforms Burger King in Breakfast Sandwich Taste Test
A comparative taste test by Tasting Table concludes that McDonald's breakfast sandwiches offer superior flavor consistency and variety compared to Burger King. While Burger King relies heavily on its Croissan'wich line, McDonald's provides distinct options like the Egg McMuffin and McGriddle. The McDonald's bacon, egg, and cheese McGriddle was highlighted by Mashed as the best overall item due to its sweet-savory balance, whereas Burger King's biscuit sandwich was criticized for being dry and bland.
Key points
- Tasting Table's Katie Mach found McDonald's breakfast menu more consistent and varied, with items like the Egg McMuffin and biscuit sandwich outperforming Burger King's offerings.
- Burger King's menu is dominated by Croissan'wiches, leading to less variety; its bacon egg and cheese biscuit was ranked last for being dry and flavorless.
- Mashed identifies the McDonald's bacon, egg, and cheese McGriddle as the top breakfast sandwich, praising its balance of sweet maple griddle cakes and savory bacon.
- McDonald's breakfast menu has been a national staple since 1977, while Burger King introduced its Croissan'wich in 1983 to differentiate itself.
- The McDonald's steak, egg, and cheese McMuffin was noted for offering a classic combo at a low price, though the steak was not considered tender.
Background
This comparison follows recent corporate moves where McDonald's launched an $8.5 billion strategy to counter Burger King's sales growth, and Burger King revamped its nuggets to mimic McDonald's style. The breakfast rivalry dates back to the late 1970s when both chains expanded their morning menus.
How outlets are covering it
Tasting Table emphasizes McDonald's superior consistency and variety, noting that Burger King's reliance on the Croissan'wich limits its appeal. Mashed focuses specifically on the McDonald's McGriddle, highlighting its unique sweet-savory texture and historical innovation by flavor chemist Tom Ryan. Both outlets agree that McDonald's currently leads in breakfast quality, though Mashed does not directly compare it to Burger King, whereas Tasting Table provides a direct side-by-side evaluation.
Why it matters
The breakfast segment is a critical revenue driver for fast-food chains. McDonald's dominance in this category, combined with its recent $8.5 billion investment plan, suggests a strategic focus on maintaining market share against Burger King, which has seen higher sales growth in other areas but lags in breakfast consistency.
What to watch
Consumers may continue to favor McDonald's for breakfast due to its perceived higher quality and variety. Burger King may need to innovate beyond its Croissan'wich line to compete effectively in the morning meal segment.
- McDonald's Vs Burger King: Which Chain Makes The Best Breakfast Sandwich? Tasting Table
- 5 Upgrades Worth Ordering For A Better McDonald's McGriddle Tasting Table
- The Hands-Down Best McDonald's Breakfast Sandwich Has The Perfect Mix Of Sweet And Savory Flavors Mashed
- 7 McDonald's Breakfast Sandwiches, Ranked Tasting Table
- 4 Ordering Tips To Get The Best McDonald's McGriddle Mashed
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Tasting Table