Tag

Preemption

All articles tagged with #preemption

States sue OCC over federal escrow rules that could curb mortgage interest
business12 days ago

States sue OCC over federal escrow rules that could curb mortgage interest

Ten state attorneys general filed a lawsuit in Oregon to invalidate two OCC rules that let federally regulated banks decide whether to pay interest or charge fees on mortgage escrow accounts and preempt state escrow laws. The suit argues the OCC exceeded its authority; about 14 states require escrow interest, and the rules could reduce interest on escrow balances used for taxes and insurance, though outcomes may depend on jurisdiction and wildcard statutes. The rules took effect June 18.

Supreme Court curbs state cancer warnings for pesticides when EPA stays silent
politics-society1 month ago

Supreme Court curbs state cancer warnings for pesticides when EPA stays silent

The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 that federal law preempts states from adding cancer warnings to pesticides that the EPA did not require, blocking state-level liability claims against Monsanto/Bayer for Roundup and potentially stalling thousands of lawsuits. The decision narrows state consumer-protection options, though lawmakers are moving to counter it with legislation or executive actions, and the ruling specifically concerns failure-to-warn claims rather than broader product-harm suits.

Legal causation isn’t scientific proof: Roundup ruling underscores the law–science divide
law1 month ago

Legal causation isn’t scientific proof: Roundup ruling underscores the law–science divide

Supreme Court’s Monsanto v. Durnell ruling concerns federal pesticide labeling preemption, not whether glyphosate causes cancer. The piece argues that legal causation and scientific causation answer different questions, urging clearer categorization of causal questions in court and reporting, and highlighting Roundup, talc, asbestos, and social-media cases to show how legal outcomes can be misinterpreted as scientific proof.

Supreme Court Shields Roundup Claims From State Lawsuit Liability
politics2 months ago

Supreme Court Shields Roundup Claims From State Lawsuit Liability

In a 7-2 decision, the Supreme Court held that federal pesticide law FIFRA preempts state tort claims against Monsanto (now Bayer) over Roundup’s cancer risks, effectively blocking thousands of lawsuits by individuals who say exposure caused non-Hodgkin lymphoma, because the EPA-approved label must be used and it does not carry a cancer warning. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote the majority, with Justices Jackson and Gorsuch dissenting. The ruling was welcomed by the company and the Trump administration, helped push Bayer shares up about 17%, and could extend preemption to other industries, according to critics who warn it weakens state consumer-protection laws. The case originated from a Missouri verdict; the EPA has not classified glyphosate as harmful.

House unveils bipartisan KOSA framework to protect minors online
politics2 months ago

House unveils bipartisan KOSA framework to protect minors online

House Republicans and Democrats announced a bipartisan deal on the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA), establishing a federal safety floor that would preempt weaker state laws. The framework includes age verification for sexually explicit sites, social-media design changes to curb harm to minors, default safety settings, limits on disappearing messages, and a data-brokers registry. The House text omits a Senate-proposed duty to exercise reasonable care for user safety. Leaders aim to move the bill soon, with the Senate seeking to attach KOSA to a broader AI framework and target a deal by early July.

politics2 months ago

Schumer urges AI guardrails as Congress faces uphill push for federal rules

Senate Majority Leader Schumer says AI has tremendous benefits but must be paired with guardrails, signaling support for federal rules even as intra-party and inter-chamber divisions make quick passage unlikely; the White House seeks a national standard via state preemption, but many Democrats resist or want to wait, with proposals from Trahan/Obernolte and Sanders/AOC under consideration; other Capitol items include the looming FISA lapse, Jay Clayton’s nomination to DNI, and a major defense budget push.

politics2 months ago

Bipartisan AI pact stalls as lawmakers grapple with hurdles and deadlines

A bipartisan draft AI bill by Rep. Obernolte and Rep. Trahan aims to set nationwide safety and transparency rules, but faces stiff Democratic opposition, Republican skepticism, and White House hesitance; concerns over preempting state AI laws plus a shrinking legislative calendar make major action unlikely this year, pushing any progress to 2027 at earliest.

policy2 months ago

House rolls out bipartisan AI draft to preempt state rules

House Republicans and Democrats unveiled a 269-page bipartisan AI draft that would preempt state AI laws, require top developers to disclose safety and cybersecurity risks, create a federal Center for AI Standards and Innovation (CAISI) with a $300 million three-year budget, and mandate third-party audits and cyber-threat data sharing. The framework aims to set federal AI rules before the midterms, but has drawn criticism from AI safety advocates and some state lawmakers who oppose preemption and question the regulatory scope.

Federal preemption blocks Illinois swipe-fee ban, reshaping banking rules
business3 months ago

Federal preemption blocks Illinois swipe-fee ban, reshaping banking rules

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency issued a federal order preempting Illinois’ 2024 ban on credit-card interchange fees on the tax and tip portions of transactions, a move that benefits national banks but could burden state-chartered banks; Illinois lawmakers and Gov. Pritzker are weighing delays or repeal as litigation continues, with oral arguments set for May 13, as retailers back the ban and banks warn of potential disruption.

Supreme Court weighs preemption in Roundup cancer lawsuits
law3 months ago

Supreme Court weighs preemption in Roundup cancer lawsuits

The Supreme Court is examining whether federal pesticide law FIFRA preempts state-court claims that Roundup caused cancer, a decision that could curb one of the largest waves of product-liability lawsuits and affect farmers’ access to glyphosate; justices questioned how federal and state labeling rules would work if the lawsuits proceed, as Monsanto/Bayer and the federal government take opposing positions.

Supreme Court narrows broad preemption in Hencely v. Fluor, reshaping state-federal clashes
politics4 months ago

Supreme Court narrows broad preemption in Hencely v. Fluor, reshaping state-federal clashes

The Supreme Court in Hencely v. Fluor Corp. held that a wounded soldier’s suit against a military contractor isn’t automatically preempted by federal policy, signaling a more cautious approach to preemption that could limit broad court-created goals and affect how state laws interact with federal aims. Justice Thomas wrote the majority (joined by Gorsuch and Barrett), while Alito dissented with Roberts and Kavanaugh. The decision contrasts with earlier precedents like Hines and Wyeth, suggesting the Court may roll back expansive preemption theories, with potential implications for consumer liability cases and immigrants’ rights depending on how future cases apply these standards.

Supreme Court Allows Veteran’s Tort Suit Against Fluor Over Taliban Bombing
law4 months ago

Supreme Court Allows Veteran’s Tort Suit Against Fluor Over Taliban Bombing

In a 6-3 ruling written by Justice Thomas, the Supreme Court vacated a Fourth Circuit decision and allowed Winston Hencely’s state-law tort claims against Fluor Corp., a military contractor tied to a Taliban bombing at Bagram in 2016, to proceed, rejecting a broad battlefield preemption theory and remanding for further proceedings; Justices Alito, Roberts, and Kavanaugh dissented, arguing war powers preempt such suits.

politics4 months ago

GOP unveils bid for a nationwide data-privacy standard

House Republicans rolled out two bills—the SECURE Data Act for consumer tech data and the GUARD Financial Data Act for financial data—that would preempt dozens of state privacy laws and establish a single federal standard, restricting data collection and giving consumers access to their information; backed by Republican committee chairs but without Democratic sign-ons, the plan aims to balance privacy protections with a unified regulatory framework, though critics say it prioritizes corporations and could shield state protections, with efforts to win bipartisan support by incorporating Democratic privacy ideas before the midterms.