
Retired U.S. Military Leaders Deny Israel Genocide Charge on Oct. 7 Anniversary
Over 75 retired U.S. military leaders and legal experts signed an open letter rejecting allegations that Israel committed genocide in Gaza. Released by the Jewish Institute for National Security of America (JINSA) on the third anniversary of the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack, the letter argues that Israel’s actions do not meet the legal definition of genocide, which requires specific intent to destroy a protected group. Signatories, including former Marine Corps Commandant James Amos and former Supreme Allied Commander Europe Philip Breedlove, contend that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) took extensive precautions to protect civilians, such as issuing advance warnings and providing humanitarian aid. They assert that civilian casualties, while tragic, do not constitute genocide under international law, especially when fighting an enemy that hides among civilians. The letter warns that accepting such accusations could set a dangerous precedent for future U.S. military operations.













